News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Leica Q: A six month field test by vvanders on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @12:49PM (#11111701)
I'd argue if you're using Canon's 35mm F1.4 at anything other than F1.4 you're wasting a lot of money.

I hear the v2 rev is also very sharp compared to the original. Although I find the rendering of the original quite good enough.

Re:The Leica Q: A six month field test by foldr on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @01:23PM (#11111947)
When would you ever want to shoot at f1.4? The low light argument makes less sense in the context of digital cameras with VR lenses, since bumping up the ISO a stop or two, or using a longer shutter speed, would usually degrade the overall quality of the image less than having almost everything out of focus. Nothing wrong with a bit of bokeh, but at the focal lengths typically used with a full frame sensor, f1.4 will almost always give you less than the desired depth of field.
Re:The Leica Q: A six month field test by vvanders on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @03:39PM (#11112966)
All the time, otherwise you'd buy the 35mm F2 and save about $1.2k.

Depth of Field is a function of Aperture , Focal Length and Distance to plane of focus.

The focal length drives how wide the "scatter" of the blur is, so wide angle lenses like the 35mm have a very "soft" blur as opposed to something like a 400mm F2.8 which just obliterates backgrounds. This is also driven by how close you are focusing so you can shoot a 35mm F1.4 wide open, focusing around ~15ft away and the detail of the scene is very much preserved. It lets you focus on a subject and give them a slight "pop" of focus while keeping the rest of scene coherent.

Re:The Leica Q: A six month field test by foldr on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @04:02PM (#11113106)
Can you give an example of the sort of scene you have in mind? I often play around with 4x5 photography, where it would be trivially easy to get that effect for a subject 15ft away with a $100 lens, but I've never actually wanted to do it.
Re:The Leica Q: A six month field test by vvanders on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @04:20PM (#11113202)
Yeah, in 4x5 you've got a larger "sensor" which also contributes to DoF. [edit] If I remember my lens geometry correctly, film size is just the other side of focal length when it comes to bokeh calculations.

I grabbed this random image from the 35L group on Flickr, they didn't include EXIF so I can't be 100% certain they shot it at F1.4 but it looks very close to shots I have at F1.4 from that lens.

https://www.flickr.com/photos/49830238@N04/25021998886/in/po...

Re:The Leica Q: A six month field test by foldr on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @04:26PM (#11113244)
>Yeah, in 4x5 you've got a larger "sensor" which also contributes to DoF.

It’s only the focal length and aperture that contribute to DoF. With a larger sensor you are typically using longer focal lengths since you need a longer focal length to get the same FoV. That being said, you also have the option of using movements on 4x5, so subject separation can be achieved by changing the plane of focus even when using a narrow aperture. There are some very technically accomplished examples of this at http://www.p1600.com/en/portfolio/london_5x4/ (not my photos), but on balance I think that these are more of a technical tour de force than an artistic success.

There's no way to know what aperture the photo you linked to was shot at, but it doesn't look to me like it would have to be particularly wide. Honestly, I find it a bit depressing that there are flickr groups fetishizing particular lenses.

Re:The Leica Q: A six month field test by vvanders on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @04:38PM (#11113312)
4x5 is a whole nother beast though. We're talking about SLRs and fixed-lens cameras. Usually you don't get any movements and very little options on that front unless you're using a TS-E.

Don't see any reason why the one I picked wouldn't be shot at F1.4.

Anyway, here's another random one that does have EXIF that shows what I mean. Just because you're shooting at F1.4 doesn't mean that everything is blown away.

https://www.flickr.com/photos/jasoncowellphoto/5534870906

I guess you can call if "fetishizing" a lens if you want but it's a very popular lens for a reason.

Re:The Leica Q: A six month field test by foldr on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @04:53PM (#11113404)
Hmm, the second photo is a case where everything is pretty much at infinity, so the only significant consequence of using a very wide aperture is that you’re letting more light in. (Yeah, you can see that the background is very slightly out of focus compared to the bikes, but the defocusing is so slight that it looks more like a mistake than a deliberate effect.)

Plus, look, I know that you didn't choose the photo for it's artistic qualities, but that photo sucks, and the comments on it are like "omg you have a 35L and the photos are sharp". Who the fuck cares if the photos are bad?

The vast majority of the photos in the group either have (i) pretty much everything in the picture in acceptably sharp focus (so that even if they were shot at f1.4, they didn’t have to be) or (ii) a close subject (so that a very wide aperture was not necessary to get good separation). Is it possible to imagine scenarios where you need f1.4 to obtain the desired effect? Yeah, sure. But they’re precisely the scenarios that rarely lead to good compositions. I.e., middle ground in focus and foreground and background out of focus.

Re:The Leica Q: A six month field test by melted on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @03:43PM (#11112988)
35 benefits significantly from f/1.4. 50 benefits too, but to a lesser extent. You get better subject separation at greater distances.
Re:The Leica Q: A six month field test by zobby on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @03:44AM (#11116299)
I would like to shoot at 0.95 forever, even in full midday light, because lenses are dreaming at that aperture. https://www.flickr.com/photos/102221463@N02/24974701115/
Re:The Leica Q: A six month field test by melted on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @03:41PM (#11112978)
Compared to 35mm 'Lux, Canon is a Coke bottle bottom. It's worse than Nikon 35 f/1.4, and it is really an f/2 lens at best, with inflated specs. Rent a Lux if you get a chance. I held Canon/Nikon in much higher regard until I tried Leica.
Re:The Leica Q: A six month field test by vvanders on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @04:21PM (#11113205)
Cool, I'll make sure to drop my 35L off at the local recycling center then.
Re:The Leica Q: A six month field test by flaie on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @04:35AM (#11116559)
From what I've seen the Canon 35L II is unbeaten