Re:The App Store: Quality control without the quality
by bad_user on Tuesday February 09, 2010 @04:06AM
(#1111823)
> Yes. And you can also develop malware and give it away on your own website.
Yeah, and doing sex with random strangers is as dangerous ... you never know what you're going to get.
That's why I'm a proponent of Sex licenses, given by state institutions after testing your general health, your mental health and the quality of your DNA ... people without a license shouldn't be allowed to have sex, to work in public institutions (since that's where people fuck around the most), or to leave town without notifying the proper authorities.
Re:The App Store: Quality control without the quality
by GeneralMaximus on Tuesday February 09, 2010 @04:52AM
(#1111884)
Yeah, sure. While we're doing this so-called "quality control", let's create App Stores for Linux and Windows as well, and make it impossible for people to install anything which doesn't go through a review process by clerks who probably have no idea about software development. That would awesome, right? No more malware!
Sheesh.
Yes. And you can also develop malware and give it away on your own website. And then, when customers complain to Apple, they can do... what, exactly?
In other words, DHH is wrong when he suggests that the App Store isn't about security. Sure, the App Store is not about prescreening for security holes -- obviously they can't find every hole or every trojan in their pitiful half-hour code review. But if every app goes through the store, and every store app can be revoked, and every store app comes attached to a known submitter with a valid identity and credit card...
You can get a trojan through the system. But you very likely can't do it more than once, it won't survive long in the wild after it's detected, and the FBI has a paper trail to your house.