Re:Moore’s law really is dead this time
by userbinator on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @04:22AM
(#11108729)
Caches can't get too big, or they'll start becoming slower, which defeats the purpose of having a cache.
Re:Moore’s law really is dead this time
by wtallis on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @04:39AM
(#11108795)
Thus, Intel's solution for improving their integrated graphics performance was to introduce an L4 cache implemented as off-die on-package eDRAM, rather than try to make the L3 cache big enough.
True. That being said I don't think the computing power increases linearly with the number of cores. I presume for thermal reasons, the more cores you have in a Xeon, the lower the frequency at which they can simultaneously operate. So as it stands doubling the number of cores doesn't mean doubling the computing power.
Re:Moore’s law really is dead this time
by slizard on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @09:53AM
(#11110158)
Not just thermal reasons! For instance, keeping caches coherent across so many cores is a great challenge. That's what Intel was experimenting with on Knights Corner - and many think they screwed it up quite a bit - with the ring bus + L2 implementation. However, they did learn a lot and a very similar ring bus based cache coherence implementation works quite well on Xeons for up to 18C - although it's worth noting that for >8C there are actually two rings -, and it should work pretty well on "regular" Xeons for at least a couple of more generations. However, not unexpectedly, KNL is switching to a 2D mesh (see http://goo.gl/SE8pZV).
It is interesting that the cache per core has not really increased over this time, being fixed at ~2.5MB of L3 per core. Naively one might have expected some of the additional transistor budget to be given over to increased cache per core, but clearly Intel has found this number to be the sweet spot.