And this poison has made it over to Mac OS X, as well. Bundles should be installed directly in /Applications, because you know, they're bundles that can contain as many files as the vendor wants! But no, there's always somebody like Cisco that has to go ahead and create a stupid subfolder anyway.
Compare and contrast
Step 1: Install AwfulSoft. Step 2: Cool! Let's run it: START -> Program Files -> Uhh... where the hell is it? Browse, browse, browse, browse... What's that folder? "RogerSoft LLC"? Nope that's some shareware I installed a few weeks ago... Browse, browse, browse, browse... Oh, of course! "WorkerWare Inc." I think that was the company's name... Oh, another nested folder, "AwfulSoft", found it! Finally, the program launcher is a single icon inside yet another nested folder. So five clicks plus some browsing just to find this damn program......
Step 1: Install GreatSoft. Step 2: Cool! Let's run it: START -> Program Files -> GreatSoft. BAM!
† ...which was never a real requirement anyway. Unlike Windows' Program Files, Mac applications (both before and after the transition to being NeXTStep bundles) are meant to just live wherever you want them to live. There were some really interesting application locations in the past—putting a Font Manager in your Fonts folder, for example. And you've always been meant to be able to keep programs that'll have a short lifespan directly on the Desktop, without that making a mess of anything.
Also, vendor names aren’t stable. What about when Flash was installed by Macromedia (but is now Adobe)? It makes no sense for products to shift around because of the company of the week.
Could have sworn that new stuff got a highlight, never mind that every icon was in named groups that matched the folders of earlier menus.
Nah, what most people complained about was that it "ate" their screen. Rather than a small menu off the the side, it swallowed whatever they worked on, and could be a pain to get back out of it they were not accustomed to the keyboard shortcuts or familiar with the new corner navigation.
8.1 fixed most of that by having the bar show all programs, added minimize and close buttons to the new UI programs (metro?), and made the bar be accessible everywhere.
But by that time Windows 8 had gotten a rep to rival Vista.
Huh, I didn't know they officially recommended it. Why? In my experience, the practice is counterproductive and based on publisher vanity--I have nearly as many program vendors as I do programs, so it doesn't reduce the length of the list much, and I don't generally bother memorizing who makes every one of my apps, so it makes it much harder to find anything. These days I wind up rolling my eyes and editing the destination every single time I install something.
Back during the Maemo years, i recall someone had asked Nokia about opening the source of their power management daemon. The answer was no, because the execs believed that it was part of their differentiation from other mobile device vendors.
End result was that said devices died a slow death once Nokia abandoned them.
I probably should have put it that way, but that's what I meant, yeah. Either way, it's pushing their own image at the expense of their users.
But tiles reversed this recommendation, so after installing something a user would not easily find it in the large, seemingly unorganized list of tiles. That's part of why there was a demand for the return of the Start Menu.