Re:It Is Now Mathematically Impossible To Pay Off The U.S. N...
by jganetsk on Monday February 08, 2010 @01:39PM
(#1110334)
Yeah, his problem begins with this statement:
If the U.S. government went out today and took every single penny from every single American bank, business and taxpayer, they still would not be able to pay off the national debt. And if they did that, obviously American society would stop functioning because nobody would have any money to buy or sell anything.
Nobody? In this whole exercise, money is neither created nor destroyed... just moved. So, we still have the same exact amount of money in the system... it's just been redistributed to the debtholders. And lots of people hold US government debt.
Re:It Is Now Mathematically Impossible To Pay Off The U.S. N...
by rbranson on Monday February 08, 2010 @01:39PM
(#1110338)
Your post script is probably the best simple explanation for why our banking system isn't going to fall apart tomorrow. Thank you. Furthermore, this article ignores basic principles of inflation and the idea that the government operates on a very long-term time horizon (hundreds of years), versus individuals who have a physically limited lifespan. While this is no excuse for reckless financial policy, the idea that it's all going to fall apart tomorrow because of this notion that the government has more debt than money supply is foolish.
He suggests that the amount of US debt greater than the money supply which seems like a problem, but: It has been suggested that the same dollar can be used to pay off debt over and over - this is theoretically true as long as the dollar remains in the system.
PS: When you almost understand the banking system it's easy to think it's going to collapse at any second. However, it's actually a vary stable system where the money you spend is actually someones debt which creates demand when they need to pay that debt back. (Simplified but surprisingly accurate.)