News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mondo bank taking £1m crowdfunding investment by consp on Monday February 15, 2016 @07:10AM (#11102887)
As usual with these things: What about app/server security. Simple token verification is prone to abuse (malware) and spoofing is becoming a bigger issue on mobile only platforms than ever before.

Server abuse is difficult, but not impossible and since getting a banking licence usually does not verify any security measures, I'm wondering what they already did (or didn't) do.

(I'm well aware of the state-of-the-art, and the usual less than so, security of banking apps).

Re:Mondo bank taking £1m crowdfunding investment by jhuckestein on Monday February 15, 2016 @08:05AM (#11103119)
[I work at Mondo] You raise a good point, indeed. Security is something we take very seriously. As others have stated already on this thread, groups that target banks are incredibly sophisticated and well capitalised. All other banks face the same issues, of course, but unlike them we can't afford to simply write off losses to cybercrime.

We see Mondo as an opportunity to build a great security culture from the ground up. We're currently hiring a Head of Security role in London: https://getmondo.co.uk/careers

If you know anyone that

- is an excellent communicator

- likes to code and does so regularly

- can think like a black hat (CVEs and PoCs please!)

- doesn't mind writing the occasional policy document

please send them my way: [email protected]

BTW, at the moment we are not holding customer balances or approving transactions so we're not a particularly juicy target, yet. That said, we've already conducted pen tests and invited a number of security firms to come and break our software :)

Re:Mondo bank taking £1m crowdfunding investment by raesene4 on Monday February 15, 2016 @08:13AM (#11103161)
FWIW, I saw that ad. Looks very interesting, but I think you may have a challenge getting someone who is a Vuln researcher/pen tester type (who most commonly have CVEs, PoCs to their name) who also has a decent knowledge of banking security, policies etc and also is looking to graduate out of technical work into team management...

Most of the pentesters/vuln researchers I know aren't huge fans of writing ISO2700x style policies documents (actually thinking about it there aren't many people who are fans of that kind of thing!)

if you're looking for non-traditional advertising routes for this you might want to post on /r/netsec's hiring thread https://www.reddit.com/r/netsec/comments/3zfj6v/rnetsecs_q1_...

Re:Mondo bank taking £1m crowdfunding investment by jhuckestein on Monday February 15, 2016 @08:20AM (#11103199)
Thanks a lot for the link :)

I'd rather hire a CISO that understands security and teach them how to think like a regulator than vice versa! Heck, I have long hair myself and didn't have any contact with policy documents until just over a year ago. And both our CTO and CEO like to write code.

Basically, we're looking for our Alex Stamos. Any more ideas you have how we might find somebody like that and avoid the stigma of the "Bank CISO" job would be much appreciated.

Re:Mondo bank taking £1m crowdfunding investment by consp on Monday February 15, 2016 @08:56AM (#11103379)
[rant mode] From personal experience I can say that true crypto knowledge is not needed as a Bank CISO. Just keep repeating 'hardware token only, hardware token only' and everyone will trust you opinion at the expense customer experience and true security. The reason that most banks use the identifier+card method is because they don't want to change. (or don't see the benefit of an improved customer journey without actual loss of security and improved/lowered cost) [/rant mode]
Re:Mondo bank taking £1m crowdfunding investment by abritishguy on Monday February 15, 2016 @09:39AM (#11103575)
[I work at Mondo]

>at the expense customer experience and true security

I always call this "lazy security"[1] and it's what you get when you hire some security professionals to "make it secure". It's a mistake to separate security from product design, the two should inform each other to come up with a compelling product that remains secure. Separating them misaligns interests, the security team will push for a change that improves security irrespective of any impact it may have on user experience.

I think Touch ID is a great example of how a novel solution can improve both security and usability.

At Mondo we are committed to investing time and energy into finding these solutions, security at the expense of user experience is a last resort.

[1]https://medium.com/@danielchatfield/lazy-security-32acc31fbd...

Re:Mondo bank taking £1m crowdfunding investment by consp on Monday February 15, 2016 @11:03AM (#11104033)
I have to comment on touch ID: Biometrics are in no way an authoritative option for the simple fact that they cannot be replaced. You can identify the user with it, sure. But you should never use them to authorize anything because if stolen or compromised, the user cannot change it. While you might say the scanner + data storage is secure, this is just temporal and can change over time. As revocation of the biometrics is identical to revoking the user, this is to be avoided for authorizing transactions.

You can, however, identify the user with something like biometrics, and afterwards request an authorization of the transaction with something else (possession of key (good), +pin (better), or easiest a simple 'yes'(less than good)).

Re:Mondo bank taking £1m crowdfunding investment by raesene4 on Monday February 15, 2016 @10:36AM (#11103865)
well whilst hardware tokens are not always the right answer, there are good reasons to resist their replacement with things like "SMS 2FA" which isn't really 2FA at all ,as you have no control over the receiving device, leading to it becoming 1+1FA in a lot of circumstances (e.g. apple continuity, skype account etc)

I've actually been disappointed to see the opposite (companies moving away from providing hardware 2FA) as other options are perceived as cheaper, despite potential weaknesses in the security model.

Re:Mondo bank taking £1m crowdfunding investment by raesene4 on Monday February 15, 2016 @07:21AM (#11102919)
I wonder why you got downvoted for this, for me security is a key concern for the challenger banks.

What Mondo is (from my reading) trying to do is very cool but quite ambitious. A new bank in 2016 will be a serious target for quite sophisticated attackers so they're going to have to do app/inf/ops security very well do avoid damage.

On the flip-side they have the once in a lifetime golden opportunity of a green-field deployment to actually get security baked into their systems before they're live without a load of legacy cruft holding them back.

Re:Mondo bank taking £1m crowdfunding investment by consp on Monday February 15, 2016 @07:37AM (#11102991)
I would really like to get an account but don't live in the UK unfortunately.

They talk about the card revocation/freeze in the app in the talk posted earlier, which is a really nice idea (next to the metadata collection). The reason most 'normal' banks have limitations on their apps is that either they will not (or can not) guarantee the safety of their apps or want to place the responsibility at the users end. This means the limits in place (usually ~750/1000 euros max per day/week on mobile platforms) are there to make sure they won't loose too much money if people start saying "I didn't make that transfer". Banks pay out anyway (at least here in the Netherlands) because the customer dissatisfaction is of greater importance than actual tracing the problem of either a hack, an abusive spouse or simply mistyping the IBAN number. Since they collect a huge amount of metadata, this problem gets easier but won't be eliminated and can be managed by good app security and user informing the user. This limitation is the same for card revocation (not freezing, that has other issues; namely concurrency).

I do hope they get a group of 'non HN people' to test it out, as they are more likely to get into the 'I didn't make that transfer' problem.

The problem with freezing cards is that transfers are not direct: freezing the card on the banks end might work, but some ATMs or other systems might have a sufficient delay to allow (some) abuse while the card was 'frozen' by the user. The question will be who will pay for the delay.

I definitely will support these ideas as they stir up a broken market, but please make sure you have you proof-of-possession and concurrency issues well sorted out.

Re:Mondo bank taking £1m crowdfunding investment by asherkin on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @08:23AM (#11109599)
> The problem with freezing cards is that transfers are not direct: freezing the card on the banks end might work, but some ATMs or other systems might have a sufficient delay to allow (some) abuse while the card was 'frozen' by the user. The question will be who will pay for the delay.

This is part of why their cards are online-only, every* transaction has to be verified with them before it can complete at the reader - so transactions are slower, but there is no grace period after the freeze.

* as I understand it, certain merchants are white-listed on-card for offline transactions - namely TfL.

Re:Mondo bank taking £1m crowdfunding investment by raesene4 on Monday February 15, 2016 @07:47AM (#11103035)
Yep the customer fraud guarantee is a thing in the UK as well (at the moment), and to an extent that minimizes the loss where it's one customer's app. that gets compromised.

Where I was thinking that a lot of their security challenges will lie is things like internal money processing systems. An attacker with access to a bank's internal systems could make a right mess of things...