Re:U.S. can't ban encryption because it's a global phenomeno...
by pc2g4d on Friday February 12, 2016 @06:59PM
(#11091580)
Yes, in previous decades the government could access electronic communications under the third party doctrine[1] that says the fourth amendment only applied to "papers" held by the individual / in their home, not to communications voluntarily placed in the hands of a third party. On the other hand, far less of people's lives was conducted online. I expect that's why no real objections were raised.
Because much intimate communication has moved from in-person/on-telephone/other-instantaneous communications to asynchronous platforms hosted by third parties, in effect much that was "private" is now effectively "public". What once required a warrant now does not. Many things previously subject to protections against unreasonable searches are no longer so protected.
[1]: http://www.abajournal.com/magazine/article/the_data_question...
Instantaneity can't be the fulcrum of this debate, because it's been the norm since the beginning of English common law.
There has to be some other principle at stake that can argue against decryption backdoors. And I think there are such principles! But I think it's important that they be articulated carefully.