News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by matt_wulfeck on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:33PM (#11089830)
this is important. The billing style of large ISPs is set up to confuse consumers into thinking parts of their bill are actually just taxes when in fact they are fees. This gimmick needs to stop.

I once argued with AT&T when they raised my bill by issuing a fee (which violated the contract and meant I wasn't responsible for an ETF if I canceled). The CSR was convinced it was a tax, their manager also convinced it was a tax that they had nothing to do with. I kept kept saying over and over that private companies cannot levy a tax. I swear nobody understood this. This speaks to how successful these large companies have been at confusing everyone with their billing practices.

Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by donarb on Friday February 12, 2016 @07:07PM (#11091621)
Actually some private companies do levy taxes. Walmart gets sales tax breaks from certain cities. Walmart will collect the sales tax on a purchase, then pocket the money. This in lieu of sending the tax money to the government and getting a rebate or such.
Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by function_seven on Friday February 12, 2016 @08:12PM (#11091898)
Right, but that's on the back-end. The tax you pay at the register is still whatever is mandated by the state/county/municipality that you're in. Wal-Mart most definitely cannot raise that rate on their own.
Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by deelowe on Friday February 12, 2016 @11:21PM (#11092525)
I'm certain WalMart would get these concessions via a rebate or discount on their quarterly filings and not at the register. The end result is the same, but as the op says, private companies can not levy taxes. Only the government can do that.
Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by StavrosK on Saturday February 13, 2016 @09:06AM (#11093946)
The US practice of keeping tax separate from the price makes this sort of confusion very easy. Why not do it like other countries and just include one, final price, which is what comes out of my pocket?

When a company quotes me a fee, it's exactly how much I will be expected to give them. There's no "but wait, there's also X and Y and Z" to it.

Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by notdonspaulding on Saturday February 13, 2016 @10:51AM (#11094377)

    > Why not do it like other countries and just include one, 
    > final price, which is what comes out of my pocket?
While it would be nice to have the price I see up front match the amount of money that actually leaves my wallet, there's a good reason it doesn't.

In the US, taxes vary by where you are. Your city, county, state, and the federal government can all levy taxes on just about anything they want. The only thing that keeps those entities from constantly raising taxes is that consumers know when a price hike is caused by the business raising its prices versus the local municipality increasing taxes.

If McDonald's wants to sell a burger for $1, it can advertise that price state-wide, and if you end up paying $1.25 in one city and $1.50 in another, that's a signal to citizens where their money is going when they buy the burger.

Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by StavrosK on Saturday February 13, 2016 @02:30PM (#11095338)
Ah, ouch. That complicates things a lot. All my trips to the US are very expensive, because I'm used to the price being the price, and it later turns out that the price is actually 20%-40% lower than what I'm going to end up paying (if you include tips). So I see a $50 steak and go "eh, that's not that bad for this quality", only to end up with a $100 bill.
Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by avemg on Saturday February 13, 2016 @02:39PM (#11095377)
Perhaps you're just exaggerating to make your point, but I'm quite confident that you've never had a $50 steak end up anywhere close to $100 due to taxes and tips.
Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by StavrosK on Saturday February 13, 2016 @02:55PM (#11095417)
True, that would be more like a 100% tax. I did end up paying $100, but maybe the steak was more expensive.
Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by hosh on Friday February 12, 2016 @04:46PM (#11090904)
Does that mean there is a case for a class-action lawsuit?
Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by matt_wulfeck on Friday February 12, 2016 @05:01PM (#11091004)
Oddly enough I canceled with Sprint for the same reason (they raised the price of what we contractually agreed I would pay). I called and had no problem getting my contract cancelled and going month to month.

Years later I get a check in the mail for $200 from a class-action law suit related to this Sprint fee.

Always read the contract. They say specifically they reserve the right to raise the cost of the bill, but if they do they provide some amount of days for you to cancel the agreement.

Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by slowmovintarget on Saturday February 13, 2016 @11:51AM (#11094641)
Most contracts nowadays contain an agreement to binding arbitration with a clause that restricts you from joining such a class.

The courts are essentially unavailable to consumers for anything where you sign an agreement these days. For example, take a look at your NetFlix agreement... or Verizon.

Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by rpgmaker on Friday February 12, 2016 @04:53PM (#11090956)
Did you end up suing them?
Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by matt_wulfeck on Friday February 12, 2016 @04:58PM (#11090986)
I was prepared to take them to small-claims court. I recorded my phone conversation (and warned everyone I spoke to that I was doing so). Eventually it came down to me saying that I'm canceling my account and I don't agree to the ETF fee. The person I spoke to (the manager's manager I believe) said he's canceling it but I will be issued an ETF.

Ultimately the ETF never came and I went month-to-month. By the way, mentioning that you're recording the phone conversation changes drastically how a CSR treats you.

Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by Altay- on Saturday February 13, 2016 @02:48AM (#11093144)
I used a fee change of a few pennies to get out of an ETF on a Verizon Wireless contract on two subsidized Blackberries back when smart phones first starting to blowing up.

The best part is, I didn't even have the credit for the subsidy so I had to give them a 2 year deposit on the full price of the phones. But since THEY (technically) changed the contract by raising my monthly fee from 5 cents to 8 cents or something, I GOT THE DEPOSIT BACK!

I sold the phones on eBay and made a lot of money (for a high school kid).

I think the charge was called 'federal universal service charge' and there was a whole guide on how to use it to your advantage. You had to sound really confident and have your contract open to the relevant clauses so you could confidently read it to them over and over.

Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by HelloMcFly on Friday February 12, 2016 @06:39PM (#11091498)
Most of the automated call centers tell you the conversation may or will be recorded prior to getting a human. I would assume this would be de facto consent for you to record the conversation, yes?

Not that there's much reason to not just state it outright, but I'm curious whether I have to give notice that I'm recording a conversation if notice of recording has already been given to me.

Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by eridius on Friday February 12, 2016 @06:57PM (#11091568)
The laws on whether you're allowed to record conversations and whether you have to inform the other party vary from state to state. It's reasonable to expect that if the other party informs you that they're recording it, it's probably safe for you to record it too, but it's worth checking up on your local state's laws.
Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by mgkimsal on Friday February 12, 2016 @11:02PM (#11092462)
> "The laws on whether you're allowed to record conversations and whether you have to inform the other party vary from state to state"

When I call up a company and they say the call may be recorded... they've just given me permission to record the call.

Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by chipperyman573 on Friday February 12, 2016 @11:59PM (#11092622)
>When I call up a company and they say the call may be recorded... they've just given me permission to record the call.

No.

"Some states currently require that all parties consent to the recording: California,[18] Connecticut,[19] Florida,[20] Hawaii (in general a one-party state, but requires two-party consent if the recording device is installed in a private place),[19] Illinois (debated, see next section), Maryland,[21] Massachusetts[19] (only "secret" recordings are banned[22]), Montana (requires notification only),[23] Nevada,[24] New Hampshire,[25] Pennsylvania,[26] and Washington (however, section 3 of the Washington law states that permission is given if any of the parties announces that they will be recording the call in a reasonable manner if the recording contains that announcement).[27]"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telephone_recording_laws#Unite...

Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by mapt on Saturday February 13, 2016 @12:27PM (#11094770)
I'm a lot less sure based on this reading than you.

The machine tells the caller that the call will be recorded. The caller stays on the line. Both parties have just consented to have the call recorded. They have not spoken about the disposition of that recording, but they're fully aware that this is no longer a completely private conversation.

As far as I can tell, there's no need for a second consent to have the call recorded on / copied to server 25126B and also server 952C... and so there should also be no need for an additional consent to have the call recorded on the caller's home PC.

Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by mgkimsal on Saturday February 13, 2016 @01:54PM (#11095160)
What defines "consent"?

If they're telling me the call may be recorded, they're telling me I may record the call. They've given explicit permission to me to record the call by telling me I may. Whether they choose to record it themselves, they've given themselves that option, and let me know it might happen. If I don't want to be recorded, I can hang up. Likewise, if they don't want to be recorded, they can hang up. Carrying on knowing what is happening after you've been informed of something seems to be about as consensual as it can get.

Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by eridius on Saturday February 13, 2016 @02:32PM (#11095342)
They're not telling you that you have permission, they're telling you that they might be recording it.
Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by mgkimsal on Saturday February 13, 2016 @08:15PM (#11096608)
And… I'm supposed to know that how? And… you know that for sure 100% of the time because…?
Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by eridius on Saturday February 13, 2016 @10:05PM (#11096961)
2 main reasons:

1. They typically don't say "this call may be recorded", they say "this call may be recorded for quality assurance purposes" or something along those lines. It should be obvious that the "may" here doesn't mean "anyone has permission to record it", but instead it means it might be recorded".

2. You're giving a completely uninformed opinion about a legal matter in which you are basically advising people to do something that might break their state's laws. Your "common sense" interpretation of a statement does not necessarily have anything at all to do with the actual legality. In such circumstances, you should always assume the worst, which in this case is that it is illegal for you to record the conversation unless you explicitly inform the other party.

Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by akshatpradhan on Saturday February 13, 2016 @02:49AM (#11093150)
>When I call up a company and they say the call may be recorded... they've just given me permission to record the call.

>No.

Ok, well then when you get a Call Center rep on the phone, tell them that this phone conversation may be recorded.

Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by matt_wulfeck on Friday February 12, 2016 @06:57PM (#11091573)
I thought about this but wasn't sure. Since my state requires two-party consent I decided to play it safe.
Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by aceofspades19 on Friday February 12, 2016 @06:37PM (#11091488)
I've worked as a CSR for a wireless company in Canada for a short period of time and as tech support for a large north american PC manufacturer for awhile and nothing I did ever changed just because a customer was recording the phone call. I still followed whatever the company policy was on the issue and spoke in a professional manner. Not saying you were wrong in anyway of course but if a CSR is doing their job properly they shouldn't be phased at all by a customer recording the phone call.
Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by CaptSpify on Friday February 12, 2016 @07:04PM (#11091604)
I think this depends on a lot of factors. In my experience, ISP CSRs know that their company docs are complete BS and will change their tone immediately.
Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by aceofspades19 on Saturday February 13, 2016 @05:42AM (#11093482)
Why? its not like they have anything to lose by having a customer record their call as long as they are following company policy and not doing anything ridiculous like swearing at the customer. Most of the time unless you are talking to a higher level, the CSRs can't really do a whole lot besides listen to you anyways so what are they going to do differently?
Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by CaptSpify on Monday February 15, 2016 @03:56PM (#11105890)
IME, they don't really follow company policy, they just do what they can to get you off the phone. They know that the company doesn't care, as long as they aren't liable. I've done CSR work before, and it's a BS game for sure.
Re:Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S. by aceofspades19 on Thursday February 18, 2016 @02:54AM (#11124341)
Well there is definitely some BS to it, as there is with any customer facing job. I'm sure you know though, after dealing with people's BS all day long, someone saying they are recording their call isn't going to phase you much, and if it were me I would be even less helpful since you've already started the call on an aggressive note and put me on the defensive.