Re:U.S. can't ban encryption because it's a global phenomeno...
by mindslight on Friday February 12, 2016 @01:18PM
(#11089194)
They're both examples of the same general phenomenon - complexity-induced contradictions eroding our rights.
Re:U.S. can't ban encryption because it's a global phenomeno...
by tptacek on Friday February 12, 2016 @01:29PM
(#11089285)
I'm pretty sure the concept of petty or mechanical offenses for which you aren't entitled to a jury predates the Constitution, so I'm not sure I see the erosion.
Re:U.S. can't ban encryption because it's a global phenomeno...
by mindslight on Friday February 12, 2016 @01:43PM
(#11089395)
I'm pretty sure the concept of offenses for which you weren't entitled to due process precipitated the Constitution.
I also don't see how a ~$1k punishment for a slight speed infraction is "petty".
Re:U.S. can't ban encryption because it's a global phenomeno...
by tptacek on Friday February 12, 2016 @01:58PM
(#11089515)
If that were the case, why hasn't contempt of court ever required a jury trial?
Re:U.S. can't ban encryption because it's a global phenomeno...
by mindslight on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:14PM
(#11089668)
Because judges have an abundance of faith in their judgment being balanced, and so presume themselves autocratic?
Historic violations don't really counter my point - even in the past the map was not the territory. Finding one non-erosion (by virtue of it never have been applied) doesn't change the rights that have eroded.
(There are places where you do have a right to full trial over a traffic fine, but you wouldn't want to avail yourself of that right).