News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by swombat on Friday February 12, 2016 @08:49AM (#11087093)
This is less unrealistic than it might seem at first. Twitter is no longer mostly owned by VCs looking for their 10x return - it's exited already. So it's now owned by the public, just by a slice of the public who wants to increase profits to increase the valuation. This is still not exactly straightforward to turn into a charity, but it's more realistic than if it was at the point where it was sitting on $700m of VC investments...
Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by roymurdock on Friday February 12, 2016 @09:01AM (#11087164)
I imagine that your pension fund manager would not be happy to take a 50% writeoff on his Twitter position that would ultimately be reflected in your retirement portfolio.

Everyone who owns a share of Twitter is looking for capital gains.

Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by morgante on Friday February 12, 2016 @12:21PM (#11088736)
> This is still not exactly straightforward to turn into a charity, but it's more realistic than if it was at the point where it was sitting on $700m of VC investments...

If you think VCs more likely to accept their investment turning into a non-profit than public market investors, then you've never interacted with stock investors.

Twitter trying to turn into a non-profit would lead to a class action lawsuit for breach of fiduciary duty. Guaranteed. (If they even got that far without the board and CEO getting replaced.)

Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by AznHisoka on Friday February 12, 2016 @09:02AM (#11087169)
So the public aren't looking for 10x returns either? Man.. Missed the days when mom and pops were all in the stock market and you had a chance to buy in on a company when they were still very small.. Seems all the profits already made when a company IPOs
Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by danielweber on Friday February 12, 2016 @11:31AM (#11088369)
This will never happen voluntarily. You would need a major event, such as bankruptcy, to allow this to happen.

There are many things in the business world where you are at position A and will end up at position B, but there are too many stakeholders who are going to lose by the transition for it to happen peacefully.

Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by criddell on Friday February 12, 2016 @10:09AM (#11087656)
I think the transition would be pretty tough to make. If they did it quickly, they would be hammered by investor lawsuits. If they do it slowly, their stock price will fall enough that somebody would likely buy them.
Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by Riod on Friday February 12, 2016 @06:07PM (#11091353)
Even assuming everyone bought in at today's low cost base; who would agree to this? Would you voluntarily lose $15+/share for...for what exactly? Greater good?
Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by swombat on Saturday February 13, 2016 @01:34PM (#11095071)
As it happens, that's precisely the reason why public corporations exist: the greater good.

That this has been forgotten and replaced with unilateral and antisocial concerns like "increase shareholder value at all costs" is an accident along the way. There is no reason why that can't be corrected.

Public corporations exist for the good of the public and are basically funded by the public - even more so if they are largely owned by pension funds.

My point, that being said, was not that this is straightforward. It is clearly not an easy step from public corporation to charity. However, that is a slightly easier step than from VC owned private company to charity, because VCs are very clear about wanting one thing only: capital gains, and they are not equivalent to "the public".

Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by Riod on Saturday February 13, 2016 @02:16PM (#11095267)
What? You can't be serious..