It makes sense economically, but at some point you have to draw a line. Should I be taxed when I cook a meal for myself, because it's a valuable service that would cost $X if I had somebody do it for me? Should I be taxed based on the price of transportation if I walk somewhere? Breathing?
It seems that we typically draw the line at the individual or household. If not there, then where should it go?
I don't know the answer to this question, but it's clearly related to the fact that work done to maintain one's own household gets left out of pretty much every measure of costs or productivity. (I suppose it's probably some form of externality. I ought to study more economics.)
Given traditional gender roles, this is one factor that has historically led to massive undercounting of women's total contribution to the economy, which could potentially lead to distortions in selecting good public policy. (It's certainly not just a women's issue, but that's one of its big impacts.)
Re:Vanguard's Low Blow
by yummyfajitas on Friday February 12, 2016 @09:03AM
(#11087174)
This isn't even taxation of non-market services, this is just taxation of in-kind benefits. In much the same way, if YHOO were to give BABA shares to it's shareholders (non-market goods?), that would be subject to taxation.
This contains the massive assumption, which is repeated throughout every economic textbook I've ever seen, that staying at home taking care of kids doesn't count as labor or economic activity. The free labor donated to the economy by stay at home moms and dads would throw off everyone's equations if they ever bothered to count it.
Say A is a stay at home dad, B is his spouse, and C works at an office. B and C both make $10 per month and there is a 20% flat tax. So total tax revenue is $4. Now, say that A wants to live a life of leisure. So he hires C to do nannying on the side, and they pay her $3 per month. Now, total income is $23, and total tax revenue is $4.6. But the same amount of work is being done as before! All that's happened is an activity moved from the non-taxed domestic realm to a taxed market one.