So my question still stands, what would be a fair breakdown of tax burden? Top 1% pay 100% of all income taxes? 90%?
I'm not trying to start an argument, I'm asking an honest question.
Unless we know what "fair" looks like, we don't know what needs to change.
[1]http://dailycaller.com/2015/10/07/in-2015-45-percent-of-amer...
The intuition I take out of this, is that letting people be billionaires is a complete waste of resources, because plenty of people would still aspire to wealth even if the richest person in the world had a fraction of that.
A better start (for me) is to ask what % of tax the people with the (for example) top 50% of income, or top 50% of wealth, should pay.
If the top 1% has (for example) 90% of the income, then only paying 50% of the tax might be considered unfair.
The only number I could find is that the top 1% earns 22% of all AGI (adjusted gross income). This is income after all deductions, etc; the amount of income the tax rate is applied to.[1]
I'd be interested to see how much of all income is earned by the top 1%.
[1]http://taxfoundation.org/article/summary-latest-federal-inco...
EX: Calculate bill gates lifetime wealth and lifetime AGI. Hint, that 30 billion he donated never counted as AGI.
It's not like it's some super secret formula that no one knows how to calculate.
Sure, you can pretend it's meaningful number, but ex: charitable donations are not deductible from payroll taxes so they are clearly not going to reduce income. Or for a more obvious example, donate 1 million in appreciated and you get to deduct the full 1 million from income. (see if you can spot the problem with that.)
PS: Hypothetically, if they said AGI was income - 95% of income over 10 million per year would you still use it? After all that's just an adjustment.
This might be more interesting...
In 2011, households in the top, middle, and bottom quintiles received 52, 14, and 5 percent of the nation's before-tax income, respectively; the shares of federal taxes paid by those households were 69, 9, and 1 percent.[1]
So the top quintile earns 52% of the before-tax income and payers 69% of all taxes. The bottom quintile earns 5% of all before-tax income and pays 1% of the taxes.
Market income consists of labor income, business income, capital gains (profits realized from the sale of assets), capital income excluding capita l gains, income received in retirement for past services, and other sources of income.
That 30 billion Gates donated would could for 0 on that scale making it BS. Use of a company jet for 1 year, 0.
PS: Of course it's also pretending the top 0.01% is the same as the top 1%.
Reality is they are not paying 50% of income tax as social security is a federal tax on income. There are also plenty of regressive taxes. Pay for lunch that's taxed, pay for an accountant free. Guess who spends more on accountants?
What would you consider a "fair" share of the top 1%'s wealth?