News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UCLA has published a powerful new image-detection algorithm by kristopolous on Thursday February 11, 2016 @02:50PM (#11082675)
The crazier thing is that releasing the source code like this, at least to me, is quite unusual.

I've read a number of academic papers where I had to email the authors and ask nicely for the source code; much of the time not getting a response.

You'd think the academic community would be on the forefront of embracing the new open intellectual movement...

Re:UCLA has published a powerful new image-detection algorithm by Houshalter on Thursday February 11, 2016 @10:24PM (#11085097)
See this comment: https://www.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/39yj8y/why...

>The code is a mess - Most code is written by grad students, it's often sloppy scripts that are duck taped together to get the numbers and graphs needed for the paper. I know some students who essentially have to rebuild things from scratch if they need to expand on what they did for their thesis. Releasing this type of code is embarrassing to the dept, advisor, and student.

>Don't want to support it - Even with disclaimers, there'll inevitably be someone who downloads the code, and emails asking for help/support. Depending on the quality of the code some may even claim that your results are false because they couldn't get it running on their application. I'm all for peer review and agree that code should be available, and further i know that the scenario is probably a rare occurrence, but still some would rather not publish it to avoid it entirely.

>Simply don't know where or how - granted i'm in the engineering school (not cs) so milage may vary, but you'd be surprised how many students i've talked to that just don't know much about github or repositories (even svn).

> There's no incentive - students are already overworked, what benefits do they gain from publishing their code? It helps academic research, yes. But most just want to finish their phd and move on to the next thing, anything else just takes time away from them accomplishing that goal.

>Funding conflicts - part of the code i use was developed by another student who was funded by a particular grant where a deliverable was required at the end. Thus, anything i release cannot include that code, which inevitably breaks the rest. I do not know the particulars of the grant or why it is not allowed to be released, this is just the response i receive when i ask to put my code online.

Re:UCLA has published a powerful new image-detection algorithm by OvidNaso on Friday February 12, 2016 @06:17AM (#11086498)
That is interesting, but really only the first point is outside the scope of issues that would be addressed or rectified if the academic community as a whole were to embrace an open culture.
Re:UCLA has published a powerful new image-detection algorithm by paulmd on Thursday February 11, 2016 @04:27PM (#11083398)
The problem is that survival and prestige in the academic community is directly related to publications. Also, journals don't accept non-novel research. So helping someone scoop your current or future research directly hurts you.

Obviously that's not a good thing, but it's a pretty straightforward response to the circumstances of academic papers. It has all kinds of other side-effects too: salami slicing, non-reproducible results, publication bias, etc.

Re:UCLA has published a powerful new image-detection algorithm by jrock08 on Thursday February 11, 2016 @06:49PM (#11084288)
Lets, be honest, it's not like academics is the only place this happens. CS labs are essentially small companies (1 CEO, 2-3 senior members, and 5-10 junior members). The only difference is that the company produces papers, producing usable code that you support is actually very hard and takes away from the work that actually matters. I'm actually much less worried about being scooped by releasing my code, and much more worried about having to answer emails asking me how to get the hacked together code to run on their machine or their dataset.
Re:UCLA has published a powerful new image-detection algorithm by lotsoflumens on Thursday February 11, 2016 @03:03PM (#11082767)
I think that's changing very quickly. It's happening much more now because software is everywhere, and paper publication lags are still months and sometimes years out.
Re:UCLA has published a powerful new image-detection algorithm by jsprogrammer on Thursday February 11, 2016 @02:54PM (#11082710)
The University of California is supposed to be copying and freely publishing all output of their researchers.