Re:How the Internet will disrupt higher education’s most val...
by xenophon on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @06:40PM
(#11069729)
Can you provide an example of "many people 'binning' Ivy resumes?" I'd also request evidence that reputation is fluid in the field of education, because this seems patently contradicted by the facts. Especially in education, there is a strong network effect catalyzed by one simple notion -- the oldest universities have had the most time to accumulate capital. They deploy this capital to attract the best students (financial aid, facilities) and the best professors (endowed professorships, grants, facilities).
Working in concert and amplifying each other over time, these factors are responsible, ultimately, for creating the benefits that we all perceive as intrinsic to an Ivy League education -- namely, engaging and networking with lots of smart and motivated peers and mentors.
Re:How the Internet will disrupt higher education’s most val...
by Retric on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:44PM
(#11070619)
I have actually seen this happen.
In the private sector there is a bias to cut out overqualified candidates ex: MS or several years experience for entry level work. The assumption is someone may need a job now in a downturn, but that would move on quickly or have higher salary expectations.
Asking about it someone also said "People also flat out lie which makes a significant qualification / role mismatch suspicious."
And finally, I suspect there may be some jealousy involved.
Reputation is also very fluid over time, Yale arguably took a big if likely short term hit from George W. Bush. Of course with 5 presidents Yale clearly has some serious connections.
I have even seen things swing both ways as schools are looked at as a great talent source. This lets less capable people in on reputation. Resulting in a backlash where people think X is overrated.
PS: Don't forget the supply of Genius is smaller than the number of slots at top schools and many of them take other paths. So, you got a pool that's above average, but not that far above average.