I'm seeing a lot of contention over selling a license for a product. Would it be a viable workaround to sell installation media? I know OpenBSD sells CDs of its releases, though I am not sure I know the details of that (there seems to be a difference between the OpenBSD CDs and the OpenBSD Foundation).
OpenBSD is also Canadian which is neither American or Japanese [which is the part the original parent was talking about] so I don't know their tax laws at all. :/
Individual donations and corporate donations are a course that don't require that level of expertise to execute on as a revenue source.
Running a for-profit that sells software licenses is the cheapest way to comply if you intend to sell software licenses as you don't need to pay a 3rd party to prepare taxes for your LLC and advise you on how to keep your 501(c)3 exemption.
Either way, you make a really good point. Just getting tax exempt status and dealing with processing invoices would be a huge hassle for probably the vast majority of FOSS projects, which may have a vibrant community but are really just a handful of people in various parts of the world pushing commits to a repo.
It seems like there could be a great opportunity for some kind of platform company that handled all this hassle for FOSS projects that want to offer paid licenses.
FOSS expenses are generally related to giving the developers money to do X or for infrastructure. [e.g. Pay for bug bounties, pay for security audits, FreeBSD's utility bills for electricity]
At which point, it isn't "donated merchandise" as you are paying for some of the contributions and/or using sales to fund your infrastructure. That is a slippery slope to audits which is the sort of mess that Patio11 is trying to avoid on his end by exporting it to the FOSS end.
Except, this time, instead of line items its integral to the entire code for the project in some cases which risks calling the entire project into question. [e.g. security audits, paying for infrastructure]
> It seems like there could be a great opportunity for some kind of platform company that handled all this hassle for FOSS projects that want to offer paid licenses.
This isn't a SaaS platform opportunity. This is a "You have to pay a CPA and a Non-Profit Tax Attorney" situation to make sure you are on the right side of the law with the entire process from end to end.
https://blogs.gnome.org/jnelson/2014/06/30/the-new-501c3-and...
> The requests for clarification contained mostly non-surprising questions. For example, “Describe whether your organization provides any goods or services for a fee.” (We don’t.) Some were odd: “Will any of your directors or employees reside at your facility [i.e. our office]?” (Ah…no.)
> You have a substantial nonexempt purpose because you develop software published under open source compatible licenses that authorize use by any person for any purpose, including nonexempt purposes such as commercial, recreational, or personal purposes, including campaign intervention and lobbying.
These are the sort of questions you get asked as part of the 501(c)3 process and this would qualify as "providing any goods or services for a fee" almost certainly.
Really, in order to sell licenses like Patio11 would like, you need to be a For Profit entity. You have no chance of going any other direction.
For sure. It's definitely not a purely software oppirtunity.
I'm just looking at the situation and seeing something interesting: there are companies that have the money and the will to pay for FOSS projects, and there are FOSS projects that would benefit from the money, but due to their small scale they can't reasonably deal with all the hassle involved in becoming an entity that can take advantage of the mo ey companies are willing to spend. Maybe some kind of third party could centralize that hassle and make it super easy for FOSS projects to get some useful cash. I have no idea how that would be structured or even if the market is there or if the unit economics would make sense.
FreeBSD, Apache, etc.
This being the case, it made sense to point the obvious problem with the "sell a license" issue. I'm not saying a for-profit is "wrong" but you aren't taking tax deductible donations if you are running a for-profit.
No. That is absurdly wrong.
https://www.irs.gov/Charities-&-Non-Profits/Substantially-re...
> To determine if a business activity is substantially related requires examining the relationship between the activities that generate income and the accomplishment of the organization's exempt purpose. Trade or business is related to exempt purposes, in the statutory sense, only when the conduct of the business activities has causal relationship to achieving exempt purposes (other than through the production of income). The causal relationship must be substantial. The activities that generate the income must contribute importantly to accomplishing the organization's exempt purposes to be substantially related.
i.e. The activity has to have a causal relationship to the exempt purpose regardless of the profit motive.
Good luck convincing people software licenses qualify in the current environment without a CPA and a Tax Attorney managing things end to end.
It can be done but not from the angle you claim. It has to be done for the direction of "This is our exempt purpose and by providing X we further that purpose despite the monetary gain to cover expenses."
Selling a product [even as a software license], iirc, is a legal mess akin to what he is complaining about.
https://www.irs.gov/Charities-&-Non-Profits/Unrelated-Busine...
https://www.irs.gov/Charities-&-Non-Profits/Charitable-Organ...
So you'd need to be careful not to stray out of those exemptions which means you can't pay people among other things. Patio11 really just wants to shift the tax compliance mess onto the OSS which I sort of get but at the same is alot more convoluted than a business donation in the US.
Unrelated business income is a very risky business for any sort of non-profit endeavor because it risks you losing your non-profit status.
Patio11 is basically saying "Run a for-profit company for FOSS" operations.