I'd guess that only a small minority of the population have a sound idea of what arbitration or indemnification are for example.
And if a signature can be substituted for informed consent, well I have this crayon signature from a child promising me a billion dollars if I let them play one of my video games. The signature clearly outlines that they understood and consented to the agreement.
They can understand the simple contract far better than an adult can understand the average legal heavy contract. Any reasoning to not give contractual capacity to a minor (especially one who is able to read/write) applies just as well to the average individual.
They do. They only agree because they realize it would never be enforced. Maybe a really young child wouldn't, but a preteen would know similar amounts as an 18 year old. That said, most 18 year olds don't really comprehend how much it will take to pay back their college loans and many, once they figure it out, say they wouldn't have agreed. There are also many who take out pay day loans not realizing how bad a deal it would be who would not have taken them had they understood the true costs.
>Because this can pretty much be generalized to all minors
There is nothing you can generalize between a 2 year old and a 16 year old that couldn't also be generalized to someone 18+.
The information is there, if they do the math. Failure to crunch the numbers is, in my opinion and in the law's, not an excuse to void a contract. Changes like credit card statements showing the results of paying only the minimum payment only do the math for you, not relay novel information. They are only valuable in the sense that people can no longer not do the math and remain ignorant, because it is already done for them.
>prove with clear and convincing evidence
Clear and convincing evidence is a set of evidence required to reach the point. It is in-between preponderance of the evidence and beyond a reasonable doubt.
Mathematically speaking, no matter how much evidence you have, you can never reach a full proof that someone did some action. You might get one hundred 9's, but you will never get one 100. But legally, you don't need to. Even the highest standard of evidence does not require a 100% certainty. But I'm not even saying we go with the highest, I'm saying go with clear and convincing.
(Clear and convincing is, from what I've seen, the standard needed to award punitive damages resulting from fraud in a civil case. Preponderance is needed for more exact damages. Beyond a reasonable doubt is needed for criminal prosecution for fraud.)
If we required this to be an adult that the world would be full of children. Granted, I personally want this. I would like to make 'I didn't read/understand the contract' valid reason to break a contract unless the other party could prove with clear and convincing evidence you read and understood the contract... but I realize this would bring our society to a halt and would require a significant rework to fix. We live in a society that abuses consent and to swap to one that doesn't will not be an easy task.