We have laws against killing people.
They had laws against killing people back then too. Why weren't those laws effective?
For example, the only reason the FDA had the power to go against Elixir sulfanilamide was that it was mislabeled, not that it was killing people.
You also have laws against copyright infringement. And just as you can't unsee an illegally downloaded movie, you can't unkill a man.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unethical_human_experimentatio...
Government is not better, than private companies.
To an extent, you are right. On the other hand, those are usually (and correctly) regarded as government failures rather than as how things are supposed to work.
Reflexive secrecy is antithetical to democratic government, but that's a completely different issue.
A government which is tightly constrained in the use of violence by laws and social custom is vastly preferable to a free market in violence.
You've posed a false dichotomy. No one is talking about a free market in violence. A free market is tightly constrained by social custom, ostracism, and economic forces that are often more powerful than law. Lack of regulation does not make violence any more tolerable.
Re:The Rent-Seeking Is Too Damn High
by ricardobeat on Sunday February 07, 2016 @07:50PM
(#11055821)
A free market is only constrained by the morality of individuals, which as everybody knows can quickly detour from the social custom. Ostracism is never a concern if you have power and/or money. A lack of regulation doesn't make violence more tolerable, but makes it more appealing.
> A free market is only constrained by the morality of individuals
It really isn't even very constrained by that. It helps if people are generally virtuous, but even an institution where the majority of the people are of good moral character, can display pathological behavior if it's poorly designed.
A free market is only constrained by the morality of individuals
There is no one who advocates for free markets who advocates against laws. Killing people is murder, hurting them is causing injury, etc...
It's constrained by laws, ethics, and economic forces.
Re:The Rent-Seeking Is Too Damn High
by ricardobeat on Sunday February 07, 2016 @08:23PM
(#11055919)
That sentence wasn't in a vacuum, read the parent posts for context.
Unfortunately, no one wants to see the elephant in the room. Both types of entities will do (or at least have the risk-of doing) what is in their own best interest. But only one can have a violence-backed monopoly advantage.