News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FOQ – Frequently Obnoxious Questions When Doing an Open S... by dalke on Sunday February 07, 2016 @05:01PM (#11055115)
You say "see ...", but I've already commented on that comment.

Your analogy with Torvalds isn't that relevant. Building an init daemon didn't conflict with the long-term goals, and the advantages are reasonably clear.

Consider the FOQ "Why is Taskwarrior written in C++ and not something hackable".

We can construct a similar question to pose to Torvalds - "Why is git written in C and not a more modern language like C++?"

We know what Torvalds thinks of C++ ("C++ is a horrible language") and of that proposal.

If he ignored or blew off the first email to suggest rewriting git in C++ then we know exactly where git would be.

This demonstrates that your argument concerning "can you implement X, Y, and Z for me, it would make my life much better" has little predictive or even explanatory power.

Re:FOQ – Frequently Obnoxious Questions When Doing an Open S... by gravypod on Sunday February 07, 2016 @05:54PM (#11055375)
I will again re-quote myself.

"But in the end, I am not talking about the devops around the application. The only opinion that really matters there is the one coming from the project owner. Your obvious attempt straw-man is nothing but opaque."

I am simply addressing the section about the feature requests.

You on the other hand are painting my argument as something it is not about.

Edit: By features I mean anything under "Why Didn't You Implement My Favorite Feature?"

My comments are solely on that section.