Add $x to each unit of carbon and put it in a fund that the federal government has no access to. Then, at the end of each year, empty the fund completely by sending checks to each citizen.
Unfortunately thanks to incompetence in how this plan was sold by the previous government and an aggressive campaign against it by the opposition, that government lost the following election and now we have the worst of all worlds: carbon tax repealed (the only country going backwards in this regard AFAIK), compensation retained (the incoming government being too spineless to scrap it, despite themselves declaring a budget emergency) and a new braindead "direct action" policy where we now give tax dollars to polluters to encourage them to tone it down (stupidly inefficient and another hit to the budget).
(1) According to income or need? Then it's just wealth redistribution.
(2) Exactly the same amount for each citizen? The farmer who needs his truck pays a lot, and gets back $x. Stock broker who lives and works in Manhattan and doesn't own a car pays little, but also gets back $x.
(3) Exactly in proportion to how much carbon each person used? This accomplishes nothing except adding a layer of bureaucracy (you pay $n in carbon tax and get back $n-20% after government processing).
2) The farmer would either pass the cost along to the customer, including the stock broker, or would ideally switch to low carbon alternatives. Over time, lower carbon emitting farmers would be more cost efficient and would gain marketshare.
3) A carbon tax would be largely invisible to most people. It would be collected from oil refineries and power plants, primarily.
Also, that is a tax, as much as Social Security is a tax+redistribution program. It is sort of a reverse paygo, though, committing a spending program for all new tax dollars.
7B * $10 / 320M population = $218.75 per person.
In case anyone was curious.
Probably we can do something simpler than nostromo's plan. Pair the oil tax with a drop in the bottom tax bracket from 10% to 7%. That's about revenue neutral.
If congress can't increase the gas tax to support the highways how are they ever going to support something like a tax on oil to support clean transport?
While that is from 2014, this table suggests that imports didn't change significantly, up or down, in 2015 through November [2].
[1] http://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.cfm?id=727&t=6 [2] https://www.eia.gov/dnav/pet/hist/LeafHandler.ashx?n=pet&s=m...
Whether such a law can be passed is an entirely separate question from whether it's a good idea. And it is a good idea.
It's the perfect time to enact a carbon tax, even if it is limited to oil. This will boost the ROI of new energy technology and open up more private investment dollars.
One way to get bipartisan support may be to put the tax on imported (not domestic) oil.