Re:Last speaker of ancient language of Bo dies
by simon_ on Friday February 05, 2010 @11:50AM
(#1103965)
Don't you think it's a little premature to conclude that the quality of her brain (and not, say, geography) accounts for the difference?
Re:Last speaker of ancient language of Bo dies
by tman on Friday February 05, 2010 @12:29PM
(#1104120)
Uh, no, this subject is a tangent and we shouldn't really get into it here.
However, a couple of general statements: There are reams of genetic and psychometric data available. More than enough to develop pretty good idea when and where the most probable selection events for good brain genes occurred and how fast they spread. Your word 'premature' tells me something about your acquaintance with that data.
Also, there is one very simple rule: totally genetically isolated communities only have access to their own mutations. Their population is small, so the number of mutations is also small. Non-isolated communities get swept by every positive selection event that comes along.
Re:Last speaker of ancient language of Bo dies
by simon_ on Friday February 05, 2010 @01:07PM
(#1104279)
I agree that this is a tangent - my point was that it's not a relevant tangent because (without disagreeing on any of your genetics) this woman's odds of becoming a professor after being born in a tiny soon-to-be-extinct tribe on a tiny island in the Bay of Bengal were negligible regardless of her intelligence or genes.
Some Google searching brings up an article with a descriptions of mitochondrial sequencing done on the Andamanese. Apparently they are of African pygmoid descent.
It's a rather good object lesson -- if you want to be a professor (the one on the right), don't let your ancestors get trapped in a genetic backwater for tens of thousands of years, missing out on all those good brain gene selection events.
EDIT: Not pygmoid after all. The pygmoid features are the product of convergent evolution. The evolutionary trend towards small stature seems to be due to resource competition from living on an island with barely enough space to support human habitation. It looks like they came through southern Asia.