Re:Tell HN: readwriteweb.com Canvassing HN'ers for their 'HN...
by harpastum on Friday February 05, 2010 @02:06PM
(#1104476)
The issue there is that unless you're posting a link to a blog entry you wrote (that allows you to make that such a disclaimer), HN will only display the link. I don't think we should start encouraging content-less blog entries that allow us to fully disclose that we're being told to post something. Just post it if it's worth posting, don't if it's not.
I don't particularly see anything wrong with this as long as there is a degree of transparency and the poster adds an initial comment to the effect that:
Bob from example.com asked me to post this and since it is clearly neat, I have.
or
Bob from example.com asked me to post this and since he paid me $500, I have.
... as appropriate.