Re:State law: You can't say bad things about a business
by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @04:49PM
(#11030052)
> Different state, but a TX judge ruled very, very similar action against PP a crime.
No, the indictments against the video makers weren't for anything analogous to what "ag-gag" laws address; the indictments were for criminal violations of generally-applicable laws that apply whether or not a video is being made and whether or not the purpose of the act is to present information about a particular business: they were for falsifying government documents with intent to defraud, and for violating a law prohibiting offers to purchase human organs.
This is very different from laws which directly prohibit actions because they are taken to publicize (whether accurately or in a distorted manner) what a business is doing. This is just saying that an intent to make a video doesn't exempt you from generally applicable criminal laws.
No, the indictments against the video makers weren't for anything analogous to what "ag-gag" laws address; the indictments were for criminal violations of generally-applicable laws that apply whether or not a video is being made and whether or not the purpose of the act is to present information about a particular business: they were for falsifying government documents with intent to defraud, and for violating a law prohibiting offers to purchase human organs.
This is very different from laws which directly prohibit actions because they are taken to publicize (whether accurately or in a distorted manner) what a business is doing. This is just saying that an intent to make a video doesn't exempt you from generally applicable criminal laws.