So that's why every professional organization spells it out explicitly.
Attempts to give items worth in excess of 'x' are to be reported to management, all gifts beyond a ball-point pen or a base-ball cap are to be refused.
That sort of thing.
Have read here: http://www.nytco.com/press/ethics.html
For how it is done in a real news outlet.
You do it for their protection too.
The typical errors of young-adulthood are not those of moral incompetence, but simple bad judgement.
If he initiated this kind of behaviour then I'm with you. If he was approached by a company first and they promised him some goodies in exchange for a write-up with the note that 'everybody does it' then you get in to a gray area.
After that he's definitely not in the clear for not going higher up and asking his boss about this, and TC is not in the clear for not spelling this sort of stuff out to journalists and interns alike.
As for ethics, TC reaps what it sows.
This is Exactly the type of error 17 year olds make.
>Adolescents frequently know the difference between right and wrong, but they have diminished capacities to understand and process information, to communicate, to abstract from mistakes and learn from experience, to engage in logical reasoning, to control impulses, and to understand others’ reactions. The psychological evidence suggests that immaturity of adolescent judgment is not under voluntary control. >New imaging studies reveal patterns of brain development that extend into and beyond the teenage years.6,7
From: http://www.hhs.gov/opa/familylife/annualconfabstracts/brain_...
If TC has posted guidelines on how its editors should behave and this person transgressed those guidelines then that's one thing.
But if TC does NOT have posted guidelines it would be comforting to know that those will be put in place after this incident, and that you will make those guidelines public.
Your lesson is that you can't just give anybody access to the TC cms without making sure they have their obligations and the consequences of transgressions spelled out.
Transparency is not spilling the beans after the fact (that's just damage control), it is making sure that the rules are known by all parties.