Re:German scientists to conduct nuclear fusion experiment today
by davidiach on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @09:25AM
(#11026549)
Is fusion something we could expect to become a real source of energy in say the next 15-20 years? I assume just building a fusion reactor will take more than a decade.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:German scientists to conduct nuclear fusion experiment today
by lmm on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @10:21AM
(#11026876)
We're "two generations" away from commercial power generation: assuming (big assumption) all goes to plan with ITER, the next tokamak would be a full-scale power-generating fusion plant that commercial designs could be based on. Stellerators are one generation behind that: if Wendelstein 7-X works as intended then the next step would be an ITER-equivalent.
Re:German scientists to conduct nuclear fusion experiment today
by rubidium on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @09:42AM
(#11026642)
The running joke is that it's always been 15-20 years away. Since 1960.
Re:German scientists to conduct nuclear fusion experiment today
by Retric on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @10:15AM
(#11026836)
Nah, used to be 50-60 years ago, 20 years after that it was 40-50, then 20 years after that 30-40...
Honestly, we could have working devices today. Funding has just been less than expected. Don't forget there was a ~30 year gap between JET and ITER.
PS: There was also initial talks for ITER to be a working power plant, but it was significantly cheaper to downscale the device.
Re:German scientists to conduct nuclear fusion experiment today
by lorenzhs on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @10:55AM
(#11027097)
From what I understand it was the downscaling that politicians demanded to reduce costs that caused most of the cost increase. Lots of design parameters had to be changed as a result of it, new technologies developed to get things to work on the smaller scale, etc. There was also a lot of mismanagement in the beginning, with the Japanese management being completely new to the area (the director general was Japan's former ambassador to Croatia). Later, management was restructured several times and now people with experience in plasma physics are in charge. Source: A retired nuclear fusion physicist who was indirectly involved in ITER told me this.
Re:German scientists to conduct nuclear fusion experiment today
by b34r on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @11:12AM
(#11027262)
Time to call Elon Musk
Re:German scientists to conduct nuclear fusion experiment today
by adrianN on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @09:36AM
(#11026609)
Building a nuclear power plant, something we already know how to do inside and out, takes 5-7 years. Barring miraculous breakthroughs in non-magnetic confinement technology, the chances for fusion power on the grid are pretty close to zero.
Re:German scientists to conduct nuclear fusion experiment today
by creshal on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @09:36AM
(#11026605)
Wendelstein and ITER are supposed to verify whether it's possible to generate net power… with improved designs. So, assuming Wendelstein works as hoped, we will, in a few years, know whether we can start planning an actual fusion power plant (as opposed to a net-negative research reactor).
Then we will need to actual design and build one. If we're lucky, we'll see the first pilot plants in 15-20 years.
So, we're on the same level of "fusion practicability" as in 1960.
Re:German scientists to conduct nuclear fusion experiment today
by vorotato on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @09:33AM
(#11026595)
from the article
“It’s a very clean source of power, the cleanest you could possibly wish for. We’re not doing this for us but for our children and grandchildren.”
Re:German scientists to conduct nuclear fusion experiment today
by norea-armozel on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @09:33AM
(#11026596)
Considering who's putting money into ignition research and alternative modes of fusion (General Fusion vs Tri-Alpha Energy for example) I'd say we should have at least one successful ignition experiment on or before 2020. I would honestly be shocked if nothing of note in that regard didn't happen by 2030 though.