If BABA stays in value or goes up, then selling off the core is the best option, except it's hard, it has all sorts of complications, it takes a lot more time than someone just buying the entire company, which makes it harder to find buyers, and you might not get as good as price as you could if you sold the entire thing.
Either way, you are making a huge bet on the future value of BABA, and you're damned if you do and damned if you don't.
But I believe the real problem is Yahoo being a media/technology company, Yahoo must improve its core business in order to be sustainable in the long run. They can sell BABA now, walk away, and reorganize the entire company from scratch. I am not saying people are greedy, but when you really have the chance to start from scratch do it. But I don't think anyone has any idea where Yahoo should fit. Content? Search? Where does Yahoo stand? This is why the shareholders are not willing to sell anything because they themselves are clueless.
Yea agreed. Yahoo is a bit of a head scratcher. They don't seem to be worldclass at anything in particular.
There are probably 50 different consultants, lawyers, fund managers, industry experts, etc, etc, that are all feeding her options. Plus all the other investors and board members who are all shouting out ideas.
"Raganwald! What do you take me for?"
We've established what you are. Now we are negotiating the price and terms.
---
You can't possibly predict that, and thus, a tax free spin off is the only sane option. Also, you can't just dump 15% of BABA stock and expect to get the current market share price. Its value would probably decline by 30-40%.
If they succeed and Alibaba buys back that 15% stake (even at a discount) they will have returned an additional $5-7bn to shareholders by structuring it like this.
> But the value of a declining business with billions in revenue each year must be positive.
Sure, it is - it's worth a few billion. Their current market cap is $27bn and own they 15% of Alibaba (worth ~$24bn pretax).
Yahoo market cap: $27.5bn
Alibaba post-tax: $17.5bn
Y! Japan post-tax: $6bn
Net cash: $5bn
Market value of core Yahoo: -$1bn. Ouch!
If Yahoo didn't have those assets, the market cap would fairly reflect the value of a slowly declining multi-billion-dollar business, and it would be perfectly positioned for a takeover by private equity, who would proceed to milk the company dry, delivering tremendous shareholder value for everyone...
But since the uncertainty around the stakes are so high, you get the above weird valuation of the core, which makes selling off the core very difficult. The market doesn't "know" what a fair price for it is.
Currently Y! is literally less than the sum of its parts.
There are a lot of reasons for that, but the absence of a "Where is this company going to be five years from now?" plan has to be a big element.
Investors barely have confidence in the present, never mind the future - mostly because Mayer has completely failed to reassure them.
Or, at least, its market cap is worth less than the market cap of things it owns times the share it owns of them, meaning that (assuming the consistent utility of market-cap-based-valuation) that it is either worth less than the sum of its parts, or that some of its other parts have negative net value. The latter offends lots of people's intuitions about what those parts should be worth, but those people don't seem to be putting their money where there mouth is and buying up the undervalued Yahoo! stock, so maybe either simplistic market cap to market cap based value analysis is wrong, or those other parts really do have negative value, or both.
YHOO is essentially a proxy for BABA, nothing Yahoo does affects the stock price in any meaningful way, and the value of the core business is effectively negative, if you subtract the post-tax value of Alibaba, Yahoo Japan, and cash on hand. But the value of a declining business with billions in revenue each year must be positive.
So selling off Alibaba and Yahoo Japan is the best bet, except you have investors demanding that it be done tax-free, so you can't just sell them, even though the decline of the value of Alibaba during the time it takes to do this process might be larger than the taxes. If Alibaba keeps going down in value, selling it now gives you more money than selling it tax-free in the future. But that might still get you sued by the shareholders, which is stupid.
A reverse spin-off, i.e. selling the core business, has some funny implications as well. Many employees are on work visas, which are tied to a specific employer at a specific address. If this changes, all of those visas become invalid. Obviously, selling the assets and shrinking the market cap, would make it much easier for someone to buy Yahoo.