Re:Don't Panic: Seeking Points of Agreement on the “Going Da...
by mmaunder on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @05:19PM
(#11023145)
If we could only make them understand that forcing the good guys to not encrypt doesn't take encryption away from the bad guys. Legislators don't understand that encryption doesn't have to be made by Apple for the bad guys to have encryption. A shared key and XOR gives you unbreakable encryption. A high school comp sci. kid could implement that.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Don't Panic: Seeking Points of Agreement on the “Going Da...
by venomsnake on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @11:44AM
(#11027485)
yep. Crete 3tb of one time pads, exchange hard disks and enjoy.
Re:Don't Panic: Seeking Points of Agreement on the “Going Da...
by fleitz on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @06:01PM
(#11023413)
Incorrect, if the key is shared the encryption is breakable. If you're just doing one round of XOR it's pretty easy to break the key given a known plaintext, in the same way that AES is very breakable in ECB mode.
For unbreakable encryption, I'd suggest XORing with the contents of /dev/random (assuming /dev/random is unknowable). Of course decryption may be an issue.
Re:Don't Panic: Seeking Points of Agreement on the “Going Da...
by schoen on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @06:09PM
(#11023451)
In context, I'm sure the parent commenter meant "a random key the same length as the plaintext", not a repeating key or a reused key.
Re:Don't Panic: Seeking Points of Agreement on the “Going Da...
by fleitz on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @06:47PM
(#11023659)
Some people when faced with an encryption problem think 'I know, I'll use a non-repeating random text to XOR against the plain text', now they have two encryption problems.
Re:Don't Panic: Seeking Points of Agreement on the “Going Da...
by mmaunder on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @01:17AM
(#11025009)
Three if you count entropy.
Re:Don't Panic: Seeking Points of Agreement on the “Going Da...
by mmaunder on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @06:10PM
(#11023461)
Thanks. Yup.
Re:Don't Panic: Seeking Points of Agreement on the “Going Da...
by mmaunder on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @06:10PM
(#11023459)
Wrong. It's just not secure in all contexts e.g. your example where you have a known plaintext that you can use to crack the key which then lets you decrypt something encrypted with the same key. You're discovering why XOR isn't widely used in a real-world setting.