Re:Rapid recovery from major depression using magnesium trea...
by bkmartin on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @01:57PM
(#11021549)
Do you have any examples of where actual, effective supplements have been taken off the market? And if you do, can you say why the removal was suspect?
Re:Rapid recovery from major depression using magnesium trea...
by 6stringmerc on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @02:11PM
(#11021658)
Sure, the easiest is 4-Androstenedione. It worked as intended. Maybe a little hard on the liver but that's pretty common for the type of compound it was. I say the removal is suspect because the claims of its dangers outwardly appear politically motivated.
Keep in mind this was what Mark McGwire claimed he was taking legally during the height of the steroid era in baseball (which he may have been - but if Canseco is to be believed he was using "real" AAS as well).
Another would be ephedra, in that it did what it claimed, but irresponsible people (apparently) thought eating handfuls of the pills would be a great idea. Several high-profile heat stroke cases as well. I'm not saying it's 100% side-effect free or safe or whatever, but it did what it stated, got a bad rap, and is now banned/illegal.
I'd love to see a comparison between the number of 4-AD and Ephedra related deaths vs. acetaminophen poisoning, which the CDC notes is about 33,000 cases per year (25% unintentional).
Also, in my experience, a good deal of the actual, effective supplements that have been on the market are now illegal for suspect reasons. As in, because it actually works we're going to ban it.
2. A lot of older docs are pretty much what I was getting at, re: the 'wall' of knowledge. They've got long, strong careers in medicine doing things the way they've always done them, occasionally updating their knowledge but not really putting in a lot of effort. That breeds 'know it all syndrome' which, again anecdotally, tends to be a little bit more prevalent in that professional field.