News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The maths of the paper disproving conspiracy theories don... by marcus_holmes on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:55PM (#11016976)
It always annoys me when reading about this paper, that the Climategate (parts 1 & 2) incident is ignored.

It doesn't prove that there's a climate-change conspiracy, but it was a bona-fide attempt by someone who had access to internal documents to whistleblow.

I don't understand why NSA - Snowden is an example of a conspiracy being exposed but UEA - Climategate is not.

Unless of course, it's career suicide for an academic to come within a mile of being seen to portray climate change as a conspiracy. Which could be taken as more evidence that there is a conspiracy.

Re:The maths of the paper disproving conspiracy theories don... by magicalist on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:43PM (#11017158)
> I don't understand why NSA - Snowden is an example of a conspiracy being exposed but UEA - Climategate is not.

Because when Snowden's documents were analyzed the evidence matched reality, while when the "Climategate" emails were analyzed all that was found was normal researcher chatter?

Seriously, the critics of the emails quoted a few phrases out of context that sounded bad but weren't and couldn't point to any change made to data or methods that wasn't already publicly documented. Then a bunch of independent bodies went through the emails and data and agreed all was good.

Mainstream rejection of a story is not evidence that that story describes an ongoing conspiracy.

You might as well ask why Obama - Birthers is not considered an example of a conspiracy being exposed. Unless of course, it's career suicide for a politician or journalist to come within a mile of being seen to portray his citizenship as a conspiracy. Which could be taken as more evidence that there is a conspiracy.

Re:The maths of the paper disproving conspiracy theories don... by marcus_holmes on Monday February 01, 2016 @09:27PM (#11017306)
my point has nothing to do with whether you believe climate change to be a hoax or not, or whether it is a hoax or not.

The point is that someone exposed a bunch of internal documents in an attempt to whistleblow what they considered to be a conspiracy.

The reason there's no parallel with the Birther thing is that no-one in the Obama camp attempted to whistleblow.

The reason there is a comparison with Snowden-NSA is because Snowden was a whistleblower.

The paper in the article holds up the climate change conspiracy theory as "it can't be a conspiracy because no-one attempted to whistleblow it" while completely ignoring that someone DID try to whistleblow it.

Again, whether or not there was actually any conspiracy doesn't matter. Someone "on the inside" thought there was and attempted to whistleblow. It needs to be included in the list of failed conspiracies regardless of whether it actually was a conspiracy or not.

Re:The maths of the paper disproving conspiracy theories don... by magicalist on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @08:05PM (#11024041)
> Someone "on the inside" thought there was and attempted to whistleblow

No, all evidence points to it being done by a breach from outside.

Re:The maths of the paper disproving conspiracy theories don... by marcus_holmes on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @01:01AM (#11017855)
thanks for the knee-jerk downvoting too.

At no point have I criticised anything about climate change, or even suggested that it might not be the most urgent pressing thing that human society faces.

But the automatic downvoting/criticising happens to any post that dares to mention anything like Climategate. I had to think twice before mentioning it because I knew I'd lose some of my precious internet points.

If this happens here, where there are no consequences, what happens in academia, where the penalties of being sceptical are so much more serious, even career-threatening?

Re:The maths of the paper disproving conspiracy theories don... by magicalist on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @08:15PM (#11024083)
> If this happens here, where there are no consequences, what happens in academia, where the penalties of being sceptical are so much more serious, even career-threatening?

Looks like some of your points were restored, but I'll note I downvoted you for the above. It's ridiculous to assert some relationship between this message board and academia, or that downvotes are responding specifically to a single cherrypicked idea from that post.

It ends up being complaining about downvotes with a not so subtle insinuation that the subject wasn't given a fair shot (when it was actually widely and very publicly investigated) and you're begging the question by asserting that any dismissal of the question is evidence of dismissal of the question for a specific reason, when it could just be that some questions have already been addressed and so are no longer worth more time than it takes to give a downvote.

Re:The maths of the paper disproving conspiracy theories don... by zitterbewegung on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:03PM (#11017023)
I think the reason that Climategate was ignored is because the original author had n=3 to prove his point. If his n was bigger it might have been studied but that seems like an issue of not having enough data points in the original author of the referred paper and not of his analysis. If you had a larger n you might find a different pattern also .