News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The maths of the paper disproving conspiracy theories don... by krapp on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:07PM (#11015939)
A conspiracy theory is merely a theory without corroborating evidence. The reason conspiracy theorists tend to be disbelieved is that, more often than not, their assertions are a matter of faith, and when they're right, they're right in the way a stopped analog clock is right twice a day. If someone's paranoid fantasies happen to correspond to reality, that doesn't make them more trustworthy.

So while conspiracies shouldn't be dismissed out of hand, they also shouldn't be given special credence, either, and skeptics should be assumed to be part of an attempt to suppress the pursuit of truth.

That said, A lot of skepticism is as much an attempt to reinforce confirmation bias as is conspiracy theory - and one could say that conspiracy theory is a form of skepticism about the apparent natural order of things. So both sides tend to suffer from a tendency to not actually care about the truth when that truth could contradict their prejudice.

Re:The maths of the paper disproving conspiracy theories don... by TelmoMenezes on Monday February 01, 2016 @06:09PM (#11016398)
> A conspiracy theory is merely a theory without corroborating evidence.

It is interesting that the only term that we had to refer to a "theory about an agreement between persons to deceive, mislead, or defraud others of their legal rights or to gain an unfair advantage" became a synonym for lunacy, while leaving us with no short way to express the former concept.

A conspiracy theorist might suggest that we can be controlled with language.

Re:The maths of the paper disproving conspiracy theories don... by krapp on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:52PM (#11016963)
To be fair, the more lunatic type of conspiracy theories are the ones most people hear about. The X-Files might be more to blame for that perception than the government.

Assuming of course, the X-Files wasn't secretly a propaganda campaign intended to discredit conspiracy theorists by subconsciously associating certain theories with fiction. But then again, the government has used urban legends and conspiracy theory as a cover for its own operations before, i'm personally certain they planted the Roswell story (and retraction) in order to cover up a more mundane secret project and retrieval, but just never expected it to go as viral as it did.

But even so, conspiracy theorists are half to blame for their own reputation at least.

Re:The maths of the paper disproving conspiracy theories don... by logicrook on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:18PM (#11016027)
>A conspiracy theory is merely a theory without corroborating evidence. The reason conspiracy theorists tend to be disbelieved is that, more often than not, their assertions are a matter of faith, and when they're right, they're right in the way a stopped analog clock is right twice a day. If someone's paranoid fantasies happen to correspond to reality, that doesn't make them more trustworthy.

I completely agree with that. But then there are many official truths that don't hold up to that regard. In many shady events, there are state-level interests, and many of parties involved have interests themselves.

For example, many of the anti-conspiracy researchers are trying to debunk everything they perceive could help the right-wing movements. But doing so deviate them from the pursuit of truth much too often... and make them embarass themselves in such ways.

If it wasn't for whistleblowers, we wouldn't have much truth in the news...

Re:The maths of the paper disproving conspiracy theories don... by randomgyatwork on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:36PM (#11016174)
I agree with your suggestion that "both sides tend to suffer from a tendency to not actually care about the truth."

Alex Jones jumps on any possible conspiracy, debunkers write off every suggestion as a 'conspiracy theory' so that they don't have to investigate.