Syntax extension (which in the case of macros is not about syntax at all, but about controlling when evaluation happens, something else that people do not understand about macros) is not about inventing a new, stupider way of writing for loops. It is about clearly expressing domain concepts.
For an article about "missing the point," the author manages to fail to understand both how syntax extension works and how it's used.
It's obvious the author hasn't a Clue about that.
[1] Of course you can "do it all" in any Turing-complete language, but theoretical possibilities are often much less interesting than practical impossibilities. In Python or Java, creating new syntax is so hard it might as well not be possible.
The point of the article was that creating a sufficiently powerful language, that doesn't offer easy ways[1] of extending the syntax, does not warrant the criticism that the language has 'too much syntax'.
Evidently, you are as inexperienced with DSLs as the author.
Of course you can "do it all" in any Turing-complete language, but theoretical possibilities are often much less interesting than practical impossibilities. In Python or Java, creating new syntax is so hard it might as well not be possible.
Insufficient knowledge is probably why you mistook the sense of the statement you are replying to by 180 degrees.
Exercise for the student -- find the contradiction here:
You consider 'sufficiently powerful' and "doesn't offer easy ways of extending the syntax" to be contradictory. Does that mean you consider only Lisps 'sufficiently powerful'? Insufficient knowledge is probably why you mistook the
sense of the statement you are replying to by 180 degrees.
Do you mean extending the syntax of Python or Java is easy? Otherwise I'm not sure what the knowledge is you think I'm lacking.
This just indicates the author is clueless about the substantive use of a DSL.
The only way to implement this is to vastly reduce the scope of that "intend." Basically equivalent to, "all you really need is Blub."
80% would be reasonable. But the last 20% is going to encompass some powerful stuff.