Ouch. I suppose we should read the articles... though, since there is no obvious answer, let us have our conversation. The condescension was not helpful.
Most of the comments here offer reasons that are even mentioned in the articles as plausible.
"unlikey to be" is not "isn't". The counter to each of those items in the article is one researcher saying "yeah... I don't really think so", not something that's set in stone.
Re:We're the Only Animals with Chins
by ScottBurson on Sunday January 31, 2016 @04:15PM
(#11008102)
Well, here's what this article says about speech:
Others have suggested that the chin is an adaptation for chinwags: It resists the forces we create when speaking. After all, speech is certainly a feature that separates us from other living animals. But there's no good evidence that the tongue exerts substantial enough forces to warrant a thick chunk of reinforcing bone.
That's not my first thought at all. I think it has absolutely to do with speech, but not for that reason. I think it's to create more space for the tongue to move around and make different sounds.
Just another SWAG, of course, but I'm surprised not to see this idea floated.
http://www.npr.org/2016/01/29/464893281/why-do-humans-have-c...
In short. It's unlikely to be for protection, or for sexual selection, or to aid in speech. Go to the interview detailed explanations.