IMO, 50 000 subscribers is about the tipping point for subreddit quality. Beyond that number things start to go down hill real fast. You also don't want too few subscribers, however, or there will be too little new content posted. At about 10 000 subscribers, the amount of posts should be high enough that there's always something to see.
Re:Reddit in 2016
by toomanybeersies on Saturday January 30, 2016 @07:10AM
(#11001576)
The one exception to that, that I've found, is /r/homebrewing. It's >100,000 now, but is still a great community.
I think it's a much different demographic to the rest of reddit though, a lot of contributors don't really use any other subreddits and are older.
And since most of us started visiting Reddit for the tech/programming/science content people saw that stuff as spam.
Still, the subreddit system is really the only reason I still frequent Reddit. The smaller you go, the higher quality the content becomes and the better the community is (in general).