This is very interesting and I think there might be something here with this idea.
It looks like you might run/work there. Is your "Frank" on the affiliate program just an example or a real person?
Another question I have is about the legality of it. Are these technically employees or contractors?
Snapzu (http://snapzu.com) is a reddit alternative that has a referral program that splits revenues with moderators, as a reward and incentive to grow it. Their system is similar where instead of subreddits, there are 'tribes', but it's essentially the same way of organizing communities.
Here is a link to their referral program page: http://snapzu.com/referralprogram/