Github is popular because it is opinionated--it chooses to use git in certain ways, thus reducing the complexity for people who aren't git experts (i.e. most people).
The most sophisticated users of git--the Linux and git projects, probably--do not rely on github at all. As far as I know, they share code via emailed patches. Some of those developers might not even be using git at all! They just send patches upstream, and the upstream developer checks the patches into their local git repo and then preps a larger patch to be emailed farther upstream.
I remember thinking in my early reading that git was like an assembly language for build systems. It really needed a front-end of some kind to smooth things over for new and casual users. Maybe not as heavyweight as Github but better than the main program. Can keep the low-level stuff in for advanced users.
Was that or is that still a common assessment or was my initial impression off?
https://git-scm.com/download/gui/linux
Github (which provides a desktop app in addition to their website) is by far the most successful one, I think because they define a whole simplifed and social experience, not just a client.
To me it seems like people seem to segment into two camps: those who want to do the basics (they tend to use GitHub), and those who want to use the full power of git (they tend to use the CLI).