News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by untog on Friday January 29, 2016 @01:23PM (#10997228)
This is how net neutrality dies, if we're not careful. As a T-Mobile customer I browse /r/tmobile every now and then. It's an odd place, full of "fans" of T-Mobile (a concept I can't wrap my head around - users literally have flairs of "bleeding magenta"!), and the net neutrality debate there is fascinating. In short, many think this is not a net neutrality violation because any service can be accepted as part of "Binge On" if they apply to it. It is not anti-competitive, thus, not a net neutrality violation.

Thing is, they're not wrong, per se. Because there isn't an actual accepted definition for "net neutrality". For me, it's strict - the carrier is carrying bits and bytes, and doesn't know/care what they are. For others, it is an anti-competition stance.

Here's the problem: "Binge On" is great, in theory. Unlimited video! Even as a die-hard net neutrality supporter, next time I'm staying in a hotel with expensive wi-fi, I could load up Netflix on my phone and Chromecast it to the TV. Awesome. What's the net neutrality counter argument that is equally as enticing to customers? It's a tough sell.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by exelius on Friday January 29, 2016 @01:42PM (#10997408)
> This is how net neutrality dies, if we're not careful.

Net neutrality has been dead for a long time. Honestly it was never a reality, and always more of an ideal. Transit agreements for CDNs and asymmetric peering arrangements have been commonplace since the mid-90s.

> For me, it's strict - the carrier is carrying bits and bytes, and doesn't know/care what they are.

I think a lot of people on the Internet also share this belief, but it is incompatible with the way residential broadband connections are currently priced and sold. Residential broadband uses a lot of traffic management tricks to deliver high-performance last-mile access -- and those traffic management tricks drive down operating costs dramatically to the point where it's possible to have a $60/mo broadband plan.

At least T-Mobile is being transparent here: they're using a network management trick to allow them to offer unlimited data to their customers at a lower cost. Consumer last-mile access is all about making these kinds of compromises, and at least T-Mobile is giving its customers a choice to opt-in to a network management scheme rather than just using a hard cap.

If you want totally net-neutral Internet access, it is available to you in the form of a commercial broadband connection (fiber / metro ethernet). It's also a lot more expensive because the ISPs can't oversubscribe their infrastructure in the same way and still meet their SLAs -- but those customers are paying for a higher level of service.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by amazon_not on Friday January 29, 2016 @02:38PM (#10997902)
> Transit agreements for CDNs and asymmetric peering arrangements have been commonplace since the mid-90s.

Neither CDNs nor peering have anything to do with net neutrality. What point are you trying to make?

It's entirely another matter that some ISPs use their market power to be rent seekers, but that's an entirely different issue and not directly related to net neutrality.

> Residential broadband uses a lot of traffic management tricks to deliver high-performance last-mile access

I sure would like to hear about them tricks. Statistical multiplexing and oversubscription aren't exactly novel concepts. Or did you have something else in mind?

> At least T-Mobile is being transparent here: they're using a network management trick to allow them to offer unlimited data to their customers at a lower cost.

It's not a network management trick, it's just a novel marketing trick to blow smoke up their customers' arse. If T-Mobile can deliver unlimited data for video streaming then they can deliver unlimited data for all content types.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by exelius on Monday February 01, 2016 @11:51AM (#11012942)
> Statistical multiplexing and oversubscription aren't exactly novel concepts. Or did you have something else in mind?

They're not novel concepts, but they're hard to pull off at scale. There's no technological "magic pill" here - it's just a lot of continuous improvement on infrastructure. Oversubscription makes it possible to have a 150 mbps connection for under $300/mo. Oversubscription also makes some assumptions in order to make the statistical multiplexing work, and one of those assumptions is a certain level of concurrency and bandwidth usage.

Also, keep in mind that one of the ISPs most effective bandwidth management tricks is psychological: if they make you think that data is a limited resource, people will treat it like one and use less of it. Even if they don't end up charging you, the mere rumor that your ISP might charge you more if you go over is enough to get people to at least consider the amount of data they use.

> If T-Mobile can deliver unlimited data for video streaming then they can deliver unlimited data for all content types.

Because other content types aren't the problem: video is. Video is 70-80% of consumer Internet traffic (sorry, no source that I can share). T-Mobile can only offer unlimited video because they are taking something that accounts for 3/4 of their last-mile traffic and slashing the bitrate by 50%. They're not saying what video you can or can't watch, nor are they changing the content of the videos.

And video is only problematic because it needs to sit in multiple "buckets" at once. Generally network traffic is optimized for high throughput or low latency, but video needs a bit of both.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by amazon_not on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @11:29AM (#11020406)
> They're not novel concepts, but they're hard to pull off at scale.

Citation needed. Extraordinary claims need extraordinary proofs.

In fact statistical multiplexing and oversubscription are easier to do the more scale you have. The problems occur at the lower end of the spectrum.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by tentonbricks on Friday January 29, 2016 @01:51PM (#10997507)
Opt-out, actually. Everyone got opted-in by default.
Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by sliverstorm on Friday January 29, 2016 @01:57PM (#10997550)
Defaults are a powerful thing, and usually I like opt-in. In this case, opt-out makes sense to me, because the people who care about net neutrality already know about the opt-out by now, and the service needs large scale opt-in to produce real results.

HD Voice is similar, it needs wide adoption to start paying dividends, and I hope it starts being opt-out instead of opt-in.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by shmerl on Friday January 29, 2016 @02:41PM (#10997922)
I'm T-Mobile user and on every their survey I let them know that I oppose their violation of Net neutrality and they should stop Binge On. Also you can tell them that since they are allowing caps exemptions, it means that caps have nothing to do with network congestion and they should stop using them altogether.

> Thing is, they're not wrong, per se. Because there isn't an actual accepted definition for "net neutrality".

It is wrong, and definition is pretty straightforward. Net neutrality means no preferential treatment for any traffic. Here some services get exemption from caps, while other don't. It is clearly a preferential treatment for some traffic. From a different standpoint, Net neutrality means that network provider can't serve as a gatekeeper and decide who gets better traffic and who doesn't. Here they are the gatekeeper and services need to ask them for permission to be exempt from caps. Gatekeeper = violation of Net neutrality.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by oxide on Friday January 29, 2016 @03:00PM (#10998039)
>Net neutrality means no preferential treatment for any traffic.

I don't know how this can be open to interpretation, by anyone. self-described "t-mobile fan" or not.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by shmerl on Friday January 29, 2016 @03:04PM (#10998067)
It's not open to interpretation to any honest person. Those who try using weasel logic around it are those who want to violate it. And they know perfectly well they are being crooked.
Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by ChrisLomont on Friday January 29, 2016 @05:28PM (#10999044)
>Net neutrality means no preferential treatment for any traffic.

I want low latency, low bandwidth for VOIP. I'm fine with high bandwidth, high latency for file transfers. As such I don't think such a simple statement is useful or practical (or even used by anyone).

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by shmerl on Saturday January 30, 2016 @08:14PM (#11004746)
Network management is a legitimate use case. Ripping off users is not.
Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by smileysteve on Friday January 29, 2016 @01:32PM (#10997322)
> any service can be accepted as part of "Binge On"

Yet, we can see that YouTube, Google Play Movies, and Amazon Video haven't been set up yet - so there are obviously hurdles. And why is the business the only one that can apply when it's the user trying to make the choices?

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by sib on Friday January 29, 2016 @02:05PM (#10997618)
T-Mobile has just added Amazon Video (and others):

http://www.theverge.com/2016/1/28/10859920/t-mobile-binge-on...

And:

"you've now got the option of turning it [Binge On] off via shortcodes in your phone's dialer.Typing #BNG# and hitting send will show you whether it's currently enabled or switched off. #BOF# is the shortcode to turn off Binge On, and #BON# will reenable it."

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by smileysteve on Saturday January 30, 2016 @06:07PM (#11004224)
Oh cool! I had been watching originally, but hadn't seen this, thanks!
Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by toomuchtodo on Friday January 29, 2016 @01:34PM (#10997346)
> And why is the business the only one that can apply when it's the user trying to make the choices?

Because the business is required to coordinate with T-mobile on the technical side (source IP blocks, video streaming protocol).

You're accepting a video stream degraded to a bitrate that's still acceptable on a mobile device for unlimited video consumption (which requires technical intervention).

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by chimeracoder on Friday January 29, 2016 @01:56PM (#10997536)
> You're accepting a video stream degraded to a bitrate that's still acceptable on a mobile device for unlimited video consumption (which requires technical intervention).

If you read the EFF's report on this, they show that T-Mobile is not cooperating with Google, et. al. in order to provide this service. All they're doing is artificially throttling the connection their own end, and letting the video service's automatic bitrate selection take effect.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by toomuchtodo on Friday January 29, 2016 @01:58PM (#10997562)
Is that because Google is using QUIC? Which uses UDP? Which T-mobile's BingeOn config doesn't support (as outlined in the very T-mobile docs referenced in this advocacy paper)?
Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by untog on Friday January 29, 2016 @02:02PM (#10997597)
It shouldn't matter. If T-Mobile hasn't got a BingeOn agreement with a provider, they should be connecting to it just like they would if BingeOn were disabled. But that is not the case.

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2016/01/eff-confirms-t-mobiles...

"The first result of our test confirms that when Binge On is enabled, T-Mobile throttles all HTML5 video streams to around 1.5Mps, even when the phone is capable of downloading at higher speeds, and regardless of whether or not the video provider enrolled in Binge On."

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by toomuchtodo on Friday January 29, 2016 @02:07PM (#10997634)
Are we going to argue back and forth all day about this? That seems like an unproductive use of both of our times.

I support T-mobile's zero rating. You do not. We can argue the technical details all day long. I no longer donate to the EFF after their campaign against T-Mobile. I also would donate to whatever SuperPAC attempts to lean on the FCC to ensure zero rating is permitted to continue (as it behooves me as a mobile customer; I don't care about your startup, in the general sense).

Too often, Hacker News gets weighed down in the minutia, the little bits that don't matter to the non-technical. That's fine, of course. We love engineering for engineering's sake. But if you want to effect real change, remember that there aren't any strings to pull here to do that. Its simply an echo chamber of like minded folks with internet points to giveth or taketh away.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by untog on Friday January 29, 2016 @02:12PM (#10997674)
This is a quite specific point, away from the general debate about what T-Mobile and net neutrality.

They are throttling a service because it does not participate in their BingeOn program. That is horribly anti-competitive and bad for users. Why do you want T-Mobile to slow down your connection to YouTube and give you absolutely no discernible benefit from it? It absolutely boggles my mind.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by tzs on Saturday January 30, 2016 @02:24AM (#11000935)
> They are throttling a service because it does not participate in their BingeOn program.

That's not correct. Non-participants are treated the same as participants as far as throttling goes--both get throttled when BingeOn is enabled. What BingeOn does is make it so that the throttled video from participants is not included in your data usage.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by toomuchtodo on Friday January 29, 2016 @02:15PM (#10997698)
> Why do you want T-Mobile to slow down your connection to YouTube and give you absolutely no discernible benefit from it? It absolutely boggles my mind.

Because I consume almost all of my contact through BingeOn partners, and don't watch YouTube, so it behooves me? Does that truly boggle your mind?

Why do I care if YouTube is throttled if I don't use it?

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by untog on Friday January 29, 2016 @02:18PM (#10997730)
So there's basically no principle at stake here at all? If they throttle YouTube and you don't use it, that's OK. If they throttle Netflix and you do use it, you'll oppose it?

That seems exceptionally short sighted, but to each their own. As you say, I doubt we're going to change each other's minds here.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by toomuchtodo on Friday January 29, 2016 @02:23PM (#10997772)
> So there's basically no principle at stake here at all?

There is, but you're fighting the wrong fight.

Twiddling bits for network management = okay.

Twiddling bits because you own a network and a content provider = not okay.

Get back to me when you're fighting the right fight, and I'm more than happy to help.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by dsp1234 on Friday January 29, 2016 @03:34PM (#10998283)
Twiddling bits for network management = okay.

If this was twiddling bits for network management, then they would be done at the point where they throttle all video (which they are doing). But they are going past that, and also giving it away 'for free' to end users, but only if a service signs up.

So in either case (whether a service is signed up for BingeOn or not), a streaming service is having their videos throttled. So what benefit does T-Mobile get by giving away it's 'twiddled bits'? One answer is 'to try to make network neutrality violations more palatible'. However no answer could be 'traffic management' because they are already doing it regardless of the BingeOn status of the provider.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by shkkmo on Friday January 29, 2016 @02:32PM (#10997853)
No, T-mobile is detecting all video content and throttling it. This include video files that you download instead of streaming.
Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by hotgoldminer on Friday January 29, 2016 @01:48PM (#10997472)
This is not scalable.
Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by toomuchtodo on Friday January 29, 2016 @01:51PM (#10997499)
Is it not a bit premature to argue this considering BingeOn has only been recently released?

ISPs have been performing traffic management since their inception two decades ago. I've done network engineering for about 1/3 of my 15 year career. To be blunt with you, its definitely scalable. Could you explain to me why it isn't?

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by dsp1234 on Friday January 29, 2016 @02:07PM (#10997630)
its definitely scalable. Could you explain to me why it isn't?

Imagine a world in which every ISP in the country had this system. Let's say that number is 1000 ISPs (with a typical 80/20 distribution).

As a video streaming start up, that's 200 ISPs that would need to be contacted and technical measures put in to place. It's likely that at least some of them are going to have incompatible requirements. So now the bar for a new (possibly better) video service is not just maintaining browser compatibility, but also signing contracts and meeting technical limitations for 10-200 ISPs.

Sure it works for exactly one company, but it doesn't work if the system is expanded to everyone. In other words, it's not scalable.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by toomuchtodo on Friday January 29, 2016 @02:12PM (#10997672)
This is exactly how peering and transit setups work across ISPs. The burden is far lower than you describe.

If you can't meet the technical requirements that provide T-Mobile the network benefit to support BingeOn, you don't get included in the program. Its pretty simple.

If you're a video streaming startup, you're not going to be serving content to ISPs. Your CDN is. Your CDN would have a process in place to integrate with whatever ISPs wanted to support this. If you're attempting to service content directly from your own servers, you're either enormous, or stupid.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by dsp1234 on Friday January 29, 2016 @03:00PM (#10998040)
Imagine that you didn't have to peer to level 3 and be done, but instead had to have peering contracts with every single network that your packets passed through.

Your CDN would have a process in place to integrate

So rates through CDNs go through the roof (even more than they are for streamed video content already) because now they have to peer every end user ISP, and as a video streaming service, those costs are passed on to you. So something that was previously "free" (so as not to be a net neutrality violation) has the same effect of increasing costs and reducing competition.

And then on the flip side, if a startup is trying to build a new (possibly better) CDN company, itstill has the same problem.

You didn't remove the problem, you just moved it, and it's still just as unscalable.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by amazon_not on Friday January 29, 2016 @02:53PM (#10998002)
> This is exactly how peering and transit setups work across ISPs. The burden is far lower than you describe.

Only it's not. If you need Internet transit, all you have to do is buy transit from two to three transit providers and you are all set. You'll get as big and as fast pipes as you like and at a price cheaper than doing it yourself. There is no need to make bespoke deals with 200 ISPs are there would be if everybody started with this BingeOn crap.

> If you're a video streaming startup, you're not going to be serving content to ISPs. Your CDN is.

Only if you are made out of money and/or don't know what you are doing.

> If you're attempting to service content directly from your own servers, you're either enormous, or stupid.

Neither enormous not stupid, just competent. You on the other hand have obviously never done video streaming and don't know what you are talking about.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by toomuchtodo on Friday January 29, 2016 @02:57PM (#10998022)
> Neither enormous not stupid, just competent. You on the other hand have obviously never done video streaming and don't know what you are talking about.

My last gig was managing the video streaming infrastructure for a major US broadcaster. I think I've got a grasp on how its done.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by digikata on Friday January 29, 2016 @01:54PM (#10997522)
I think as long as T-mobile isn't charging the video services actual money, the degree of concern goes way down for me. If money changes hands, then the Tmobile would be effectively hiding end customer costs into the structure of another service, making end customer market choices more convoluted, reducing customer market freedom and giving smaller companies an artificial financial disadvantage.

Since they aren't charging, there's this hurdle of having to do things to confirm the the specs of the program, but there's already all sorts of technical/marketing things that small companies need to do to access expanded customer bases. As long as they can make clean tradeoffs valuing Binge On conformance against other choices that seems not as inherently terrible - especially since in the end, mobile is a market where people have better choices then say the last-mile home broadband market.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by amazon_not on Friday January 29, 2016 @03:01PM (#10998046)
> I think as long as T-mobile isn't charging the video services actual money, the degree of concern goes way down for me.

I see T-Mo has been successful in their marketing.

Drugs aren't bad, as long as they are free :)

Of course T-Mobile wants everybody to think that it's a good thing that they are acting as anti-competitive gatekeepers. As long as they don't explicitly charge for it.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by fleitz on Friday January 29, 2016 @01:28PM (#10997279)
I think most people are far more concerned about how fast they can download things and how much their data plan costs than 'the principles of net neutrality'.

What people like about net neutrality is that they aren't paying more to watch netflix and/or their netflix streams stream at the rate of connection they paid for. Outside of political activists I don't think anyone really cares about 'net neutrality' even the EFF didn't support it ~5 years ago.

Personally, I'd trade cheap & fast data plans for 'net neutrality' (the government enforced version of it rather than the defacto standard) any day of the week.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by smacktoward on Friday January 29, 2016 @01:33PM (#10997332)
If you have to ask a gatekeeper for permission to participate, it's not neutral.
Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by sethhochberg on Friday January 29, 2016 @02:51PM (#10997985)
This is my biggest problem with it. If the integration were as simple as "set these proper headers to identify your content", maybe even with something as basic as registering the ID you use to prevent abuse, I'd feel much less negative about the Binge On and Music Freedom programs.

I'm a T-Mobile customer and I work for a boutique internet radio provider who participates in Music Freedom... so I certainly do benefit from the programs. I just wonder what kind of long-term cost it'll have when consumer-friendly programs like this become standard and less-friendly versions take their place.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by schnevets on Friday January 29, 2016 @01:26PM (#10997259)
Yeah, Net Neutrality was a lot easier to get behind when no service providers were really marketing the alternative. This controversy is similar to the Internet.org debate in India.
Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by chimeracoder on Friday January 29, 2016 @01:47PM (#10997456)
> This controversy is similar to the Internet.org debate in India.

The difference with Internet.org ("Free Basics") is that, in India, it's very easy to show Free Basics as a move by a foreign country to essentially "buy" India's poor and rural citizens citizens (and therefore, its sovereignty). Given the particular history of India's colonization under British rule, this is a message that resonates very well, which is why advocacy groups have been very successful in garnering opposition to Free Basics. Those who remember colonial rule in India or the decades following are not exactly thrilled about the idea of signing over their rights or power to a foreign corporate entity.

That experience is different in the US, so its reception hasn't seen the same level of opposition here as it does in India.

Re:T-Mobile’s Binge on Violates Key Net Neutrality Principle... by wmeredith on Friday January 29, 2016 @03:02PM (#10998055)
Net Neutrality or not, it's a shitty service. My video quality went to shit a few months back and I didn't know why. It was because I was opted into this nonsense. Which is just allowing them to throttle your speeds in exchange for unlimited data.