We are taking the feedback system seriously and are slowly testing it out. An easily gamed system is useless for everyone.
But why must demonstration of skill be limited to elite red-team style pentesting? You could devise challenges geared at demonstrating all sorts of knowledge (HIPAA, PCI, websec) basic or advanced.
If you've seen the sad state of PCI audits in particular these days, you'll get my drift. I think there's a huge opportunity here to raise the quality bar with your marketplace.
Take a look at the leaderboard for Microcorruption some time. It's public. (SF's are not, as a considered design decision for the moment.) If you do and cannot understand the claim I am making, that's cool, but I feel no particular need to elaborate.
More important in the long term than the names you will recognize are the names you will not.
I'd just want more proof than "Bob says he does a bang-up job" -- there's so much incest in enterprise, recommendations and upvotes mean nothing.
I think what patio11 is doing with Starfighters.io is orders of magnitude better. Run developers through a gambit of supremely difficult tests via a fun CTF-type game and pair the best hackers with the highest enterprise bidder. Works not just for pentesters, but all devs really.
Also, I know where to get the best pentesters because they're listed on all the top companies' bug bounty pages. It's proof of skill I'm after, not some Gartner-esque gatekeeper telling me who's best because they've "background checked" them.
Give me a system more like StackOverflow or Starfighters where I can see the work. Not something subjective like eBay or Yelp, which can be easily gamed.