News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by qrendel on Thursday January 28, 2016 @01:46PM (#10990243)
> They can't just commit people because they talked to them and decided hey lock that guy up.

They're free to assess you however they want and then use that as an excuse. Who is going to argue with and stop them? The judge? Your lawyer? Someone else who lacks a medical degree and "psychiatric expertise"?

There are so many ways it can go wrong for you. Maybe they thought you said something you didn't. I was once accused of making suicidal statements that I never did - not even a matter of being misheard, but completely making up things that I had never said. Maybe you just seem twitchy or distracted or they think they see signs of some other symptom. Maybe they just decide to lie because they think they know best.

I'm not claiming that every psych is out to get you, just that you really roll the dice when you talk to an unknown one. Hence the comparison to dealing with police. From my own experiences and people I've known, it gets worse when you aren't involved of your own free will or aren't the one directly paying for your own treatment.

In your case, I'd be curious whether whichever working clinical psychiatrist that was assigned to this person also felt as strongly that they should be committed, and had similar lack of success doing so?

Some non-anecdotal evidence either way would be more convincing, but this is the impression I've gotten considering the uniformity of experiences I've observed. Only one person I can think of actually felt they were helped by and had a positive experience with a psychiatric institution, and that was through a college health service. The only paper[1] I could find on it reports that "retrospectively, between 33% and 81% of patients regard the admission as justified and/or the treatment as beneficial," which is a uselessly broad range and could be used to conclude either way.

[1] http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1600-0447.2006....

Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by gnaritas on Thursday January 28, 2016 @01:58PM (#10990342)
I think you're remembering a time long past. The system doesn't work that way anymore. Committing someone against their will is no longer trivial or easy if even possible. You have to have evidence and it has to be an immediate threat like within a few days and it's f'ing hard. These people do not have the power you think they do anymore. The thing you're complaining about has already been fixed.

http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2013/01/07/mental-...

Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by goldbrick on Thursday January 28, 2016 @06:01PM (#10992179)
You don't know what you're talking about. Joe Asshole can't lock random people in the hospital on psychiatric hold, but a psychiatrist can.
Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by gnaritas on Thursday January 28, 2016 @06:08PM (#10992248)
Only for a very short time and only with evidence they're a danger, and we aren't talking about joe asshole, and I know as much what I'm talking about as you do buddy. This isn't the world where a psychiatrist has that much unchecked power; it isn't the movies.
Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by pravda on Thursday January 28, 2016 @10:13PM (#10993243)
Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by gnaritas on Thursday January 28, 2016 @11:43PM (#10993545)
Two instances of police corruption that have no relevance to this thread. In neither of those cases was the psychiatrist responsible and in both cases they were released within days. Dirty cops telling lies cause all sorts of problems, that's on them.
Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by pravda on Friday January 29, 2016 @07:31PM (#10999738)
Police officers, whether dirty or clean, cannot commit anyone. In both cases the psychiatrist was responsible.

http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/woman-interest-clippers-...

Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by gnaritas on Sunday January 31, 2016 @02:11PM (#11007531)
They can lie to psychiatrists to get a temporary commit which is what happened in both of those cases, and yet again you link to something that only shows a few day temporary hold; that does not support your case. You cannot commit someone for more than a few days against their will and that fact alone demonstrates that psychiatrists do not have very much power anymore.
Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by goldbrick on Monday February 01, 2016 @12:06PM (#11013095)
It varies by state, but I just looked up New York, California, and Texas and they are surprisingly uniform. Getting a 72-hour hold is pretty easy, and a psychiatrist can tell the court if s/he deems it necessary to hold for an additional 14 days (ostensibly, so they can verify that whatever medication they choose to administer has taken effect). These courts are pretty much set up to rubber stamp whatever the psychiatrist wants to do; many hospitals that have psychiatric services have these courts in the same facility. After that, although the patient has the right to leave the hospital whenever they want, but in many cases they aren't told that, or that they may need to call a lawyer to take them court in order for the judge to issue a release.