News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Proposal to require clinical trials data to be shared for... by epistasis on Thursday January 28, 2016 @12:04PM (#10989414)
> Pharmalot: What do you make, though, of the editors at The New England Journal of Medicine? In a recent editorial, they expressed reservations and set off a ruckus by saying that some researchers worry about ‘research parasites.’

>Krumholz: There are lot of people who feel the research they do is the best research. It comes across as self-serving and absurd. Science is about replicating and testing your work. We need scientists to test and investigate and provide new insights. … Remember, people may make errors and the only way to catch mistakes and make corrections is to see the data.To call people parasites who are taking advantage of existing data and using that to generate new knowledge is not parasitism. That’s synergy and building on work of others. … Anyone who holds that view is not seeing the big picture about how different people can work in different ways to help society advance.

There's been a lot of anger at NEJM for this editorial, largely because it used the brazenly derogatory term "research parasites," more than any other particular complaint. The same discussion happened last decade in the basic research community, as gene expression microarray studies started publishing lots of data, and no single initial publication could fully mine it. Now that the clinical science community is encountering more of this, and information dense technologies are being used to gather data during clinical trials, the same discussion is getting rehashed.

Meanwhile, those whose primary research thrust is analysis of data rather than generation often have more offers to collaborate than they could ever meet. They may not get the Science or Nature papers though, as those are typically reserved for data producers.

Re:Proposal to require clinical trials data to be shared for... by cyphar on Thursday January 28, 2016 @06:25PM (#10992354)
> They may not get the Science or Nature papers though, as those are typically reserved for data producers.

[I'm an undergrad research student at my university, doing research into Asteroseismology.] While this might be the case for medical data, I can give a counterexample of astrophysics data. As a community, we only have so many telescopes. Most of the work I'm doing is involved with the NASA Kepler space telescope, and several of my colleagues have written articles in Nature and Science about new techniques and results from data that is publicly available from that telescope. Several papers I've coauthored have mainly been new data processing techniques to learn more about stars using existing data.

So, from my perspective, the whole "research parasite" FUD was particularly ridiculous. It's incredibly arrogant to claim that you've learnt all you can learn from a single collection of data. Calling people that salvage even more information from other data sets "parasites" is incredibly arrogant.

Re:Proposal to require clinical trials data to be shared for... by yummyfajitas on Friday January 29, 2016 @06:30AM (#10994636)
The derogatory term is far from the only problem with the NEJM editorial. The problem is that the article was acting as if publications and socially approved results are primarily a reward for putting in effort, as opposed to part of a search for truth.

The article criticized "rude" behavior like using someone's own data to refute their conclusion. That's the biggest bit of cluelessness in the editorial.

Re:Proposal to require clinical trials data to be shared for... by ranko on Friday January 29, 2016 @07:34AM (#10994839)
Sadly, most researchers are primarily judged on publication record, with the not-too-subtle subtext that "low" rates of publication are due to lack of either effort or talent. In such rating exercises, truth is never a factor.
Re:Proposal to require clinical trials data to be shared for... by im2w1l on Friday January 29, 2016 @12:10AM (#10993627)
Creating data can be expensive. Analyzing data is cheap. People who come up with a new theory get a lot more fame than people who publish raw data. The incentives are then to suck your data absolutely dry of theoretical insight before you publish it.

The solution would be to realign the incentives by giving more credit to the creators of the data.

Re:Proposal to require clinical trials data to be shared for... by jxdjsks on Thursday January 28, 2016 @10:05PM (#10993218)
Medical research is currently a clusterfuck. It is an absolute non sense to create throw away data for the purpose of verifying or falsifying one theory. Fucking morons. Sometimes I think I'm the only sane person on this rock, but I used to think that maybe I was just arrogant. Nope. Now I am older and wiser now and I realise its just true.