Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu...
by ra1n85 on Thursday January 28, 2016 @08:19AM
(#10987938)
I'm also intrigued, and seemingly let down, by folks with degrees in "Cyber {defense|analysis|warfare}". These degrees are always laid out on a resume with other super-sexy sounding credentials and accolades. Unfortunately, the interviews always seem to reveal a lot of (sometimes serious) technical gaps. The only reliable indicators I've come to find for technical and engineering acumen are curiosity and experience. These sexy sounding degrees are starting to become indicators of candidates that don't meet requirements.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu...
by chrisseaton on Thursday January 28, 2016 @09:10AM
(#10988208)
Yes presumably this whole thing unravels when you interview someone and say 'oh great you have PhD - can you tell me about your top three peer-reviewed papers'
Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu...
by HarryHirsch on Thursday January 28, 2016 @10:15AM
(#10988596)
Assuming that you are permitted to unravel the ruse. If your company's purpose is to suck on the Federal teat, such actions are discouraged. Just look next door at the Theranos thread! For the better of ten years, asking hard questions about Theranos was discouraged.
Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu...
by TACIXAT on Thursday January 28, 2016 @11:38AM
(#10989191)
There is a certain school in my area that offers a Masters in Cyber Security. We have come to learn through interviews that people with this degree know very little about practical security, reverse engineering, and exploitation. I'm sure it helps them get a sweet government job though.
Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu...
by grkvlt on Friday January 29, 2016 @06:37AM
(#10994654)
Of course you don't need to know how to write shellcode, or have in-depth knowledge of anti-debugger reversing tricks, to write a very useful and robust security policy for an organisation, or manage a global incident response team. I wouldn't be so quick to dismiss the degree just because it doesn't teach 'practical' security. It's the same story with Computer Science degrees, which don't teach about source control or agile software methodologies, since these 'practical' subjects aren't really anything to do with CS.