News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by cafard on Thursday January 28, 2016 @06:22AM (#10987554)
To summarize: contractors can bill the federal government at higher rates for PhDs, without respect to the origin or meaning of that degree, and pass on some of it to the employee, so these employees are getting PhDs in the most expedient way. The main difference between now and the 20th Century is the explosion of on-line schools and the expansion of the "national security community."
Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by mtberatwork on Thursday January 28, 2016 @08:41AM (#10988035)
There has been a significant rise in advertising around the DC metro area for online schools. Usually the premise is the same: "get a degree|certification quickly in cyber-<insert field>|management". Degrees (not just PhDs), certifications, etc all equate to higher billable rates for the contractor. The contractor world is probably single-handedly keeping the certification industry afloat.
Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by tedks on Thursday January 28, 2016 @10:17AM (#10988613)
To be fair, when I travel outside the DC area I still see as many ads for for-profit schools. They're certainly a huge share of metro advertisements, probably the next down from weapons systems advertisements.
Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by devonkim on Thursday January 28, 2016 @01:47PM (#10990246)
A lot of these schools have historically targeted US military personnel all around the US and even abroad due to the perception of 1. Ignorance 2. funding per Montgomery GI Bill or other entitlements for service members. It's part of why the University of Phoenix was recently banned from trying to recruit US Army (or another service branch) near bases / camps I suspect.
Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by ZanyProgrammer on Thursday January 28, 2016 @07:22AM (#10987741)
So (and I'm guessing here because I really can't stand to click on a Vice link) that a lot of those PhDs are in bullshit fields like "national security studies" or similar?
Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by dcposch on Thursday January 28, 2016 @01:42PM (#10990199)
Vice runs vacuous clickbait sometimes, but they've gotten a LOT better in the last few years and they also do some excellent journalism now.

In particular, their feature-length documentaries are consistently amazing, as is Vice on HBO. Shane Smith and Thomas Morton both have balls of titanium. They go places ordinary journalists would never go, figuratively and literally.

Give them a second chance.

Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by sedachv on Thursday January 28, 2016 @02:08PM (#10990421)
> Give them a second chance.

That is exactly what compulsive liars/sociopaths like Shane Smith want: http://dailycaller.com/2013/07/03/vice-founder-famous-for-tr...

The documentaries and reporting produced by Vice are entertaining, but their standards of reporting basically make them a hipster tabloid.

Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by dtornabene on Thursday January 28, 2016 @03:34PM (#10991074)
A Couple of things....

1) The Daily Caller isn't exactly a noted truth teller itself 2) The author of that particular piece, Charles Johnson, is well known for being utterly without scruples whatsoever. He's also one of the purveyors of the extremely offensive "cuckservative" meme that popped up recently (hint: its white supremacist) which leads to #3... 3) Gavin Mcinnes, one of the founders, left Vice under not particularly friendly circumstances and has since come out as a white nationalist and he and Chuck Johnson are pretty tight online. Just some food for thought here.

Also, to back up the parent, yes, Vice does run a great deal of clickbait, but they also run things noone else will. I've read younger authors who I discovered on more mainstream sites that have had pieces published at Vice.

Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by sedachv on Thursday January 28, 2016 @06:20PM (#10992324)
It is not like that is the only report relating to Vice to raise suspicions:

https://medium.com/thoughts-on-media/vice-media-kit-warning-...

http://gawker.com/working-at-vice-media-is-not-as-cool-as-it...

> Gavin Mcinnes, one of the founders, left Vice under not particularly friendly circumstances and has since come out as a white nationalist and he and Chuck Johnson are pretty tight online. Just some food for thought here.

You can tell a lot about a person from their cofounders. McInnes was at Vice from 1994 to 2007. Vice was built on shock journalism, McInnes never hid his racism and homophobia:

http://www.nypress.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?avis=NP&date=20...

Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by tod222 on Thursday January 28, 2016 @05:02PM (#10991743)
You're smearing someone while citing the notorious author that Politico dubbed a "misinformation monger."

Please stop wasting our time.

Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by emidln on Thursday January 28, 2016 @07:53AM (#10987838)
It seems worse than that from the article. A lot of PhDs are from non-accredited schools. Some of the PhDs are from a series of online "schools" that seem to be ran by the same man.
Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by ZanyProgrammer on Thursday January 28, 2016 @08:06AM (#10987877)
Reminds me of a lot of mid-00s Army officers that I remember- a lot of the OCS crowd especially had bullshit online degrees from degree mills.
Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by PeterisP on Thursday January 28, 2016 @05:01PM (#10991738)
Why would that be a motivation to get a PhD then?

I mean, for any billing issue, if you're contracting out a person with a non-accredited PhD then they do not have an accredited PhD and representing it that way is simply fraud; and from the side of customer/government asking for data on any "PhDs" including self-proclaimed, instead of accredited degrees would be simply ridiculous.

Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by huac on Thursday January 28, 2016 @09:58AM (#10988478)
here's the relevant image: https://news-images.vice.com/images/2016/01/27/doctors-of-do...

the analysis is pretty straightforward from there.

Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by gruez on Thursday January 28, 2016 @11:30AM (#10989125)
What's the reason behind the rise of "business admin & mgmt"?
Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by p4bl0 on Thursday January 28, 2016 @11:42AM (#10989216)
My guess would be that it is easier to bullshit a diploma in "business admin & mgmt" than in law, literature, or sciences for examples.
Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by Nelson69 on Thursday January 28, 2016 @01:11PM (#10989980)
There is another axis that would be pretty interesting. I suspect that these "national security" types get a sizable and relatively automatic boost in pay for a PhD and it's likely not correlated to any performance or value.

Top Secret America by Dana Priest (http://www.amazon.com/Top-Secret-America-American-Security/d...) is a somewhat interesting read on it. There are some politically angled results you can take from it but one of the most obvious non-political results is that the national security apparatus employs people that tend to be better paid, live in better areas and have all those benefits (better schools for their kids, less crime, etc..) They also seem to be disproportionately white men. If you squint your eyes just right, it looks an awful lot like a jobs program for white men. The book is a few years old but as I remember it I want to say the average pay for a top secret cleared generic 'analyst' was in the $150k+ range, more if you're in a valuable specialty. Then the real kicker, most of them justify their own jobs and contracts, oversight consists of reading that justification, which I guess isn't totally unusual for government work but since they're contractors it's a little odd.. It's not performance based.

Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by volaski on Thursday January 28, 2016 @11:15AM (#10989003)
Why can't you stand to click on a vice link?
Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by analog31 on Thursday January 28, 2016 @12:30PM (#10989638)
This is true in some other fields as well, such as K-12 education. The typical teacher contract guarantees an automatic salary bump for getting an advanced degree,
Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by p4bl0 on Thursday January 28, 2016 @11:40AM (#10989200)
I don't understand. Do you imply that in the US any organization can grant a PhD to someone? And/or that there is no control over the requirements to meet to get a PhD?
Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by gherkin0 on Thursday January 28, 2016 @11:56AM (#10989352)
> I don't understand. Do you imply that in the US any organization can grant a PhD to someone? And/or that there is no control over the requirements to meet to get a PhD?

In the US, the big distinction is between accredited schools and unaccredited schools. Probably any organization could grant a piece of paper called a "PhD" to someone, but not every organization could claim to be accredited by a legitimate accreditor.

My understanding is a lot of the online-only/for-profit schools are accreddited by less the rigorous "national" accreditors. The traditional regional accreditors are more focused on academics.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regional_accreditation

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Higher_education_accreditation...

Re:What a PhD Really Means in the US National Security Commu... by p4bl0 on Thursday January 28, 2016 @12:06PM (#10989426)
Okay, thanks!