News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by lutusp on Thursday January 28, 2016 @03:25AM (#10987075)
Wait, what? Does this means schizophrenia isn't caused by refrigerator moms, as psychiatry once claimed (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refrigerator_mother_theory)? And that endless therapy won't actually do any good, contrary to what psychiatrists and psychologists have held?

I expect to watch neuroscience nibble away at the territory now held by psychology, until (as Lewis Carroll wrote about the Cheshire Cat) there's nothing left but the smile.

Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by DanBC on Thursday January 28, 2016 @03:56AM (#10987159)
Yes, 70 years ago psychiatry had some odd ideas. It's frustrating that you only make these comments about psychiatry - you don't pop up in geography threads to say "Wait, what? Does this mean geographers don't still believe in fixed immovable continents?".

Endless therapy is not recommended for anything, and certainly not for schizophrenia. There are recommended lifestyle interventions, but these are aimed to reduce or stop smoking, to control weight gain, to keep people out of hospital, or to help people gain and keep employment.

A therapy might be involved if a person is hearing voices, but isn't particularly bothered by them. In that situation it doesn't make much sense to medicate away those voices (because the medication has severe side effects) so the person might get a "therapy" that helps them cope with voices, and learn when and how to seek help if the voices become too much.

Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by saurik on Thursday January 28, 2016 @04:39AM (#10987296)
Fixed immovable continents is a theory that has reasonable prediction power: if you assume that, you can do lots of things without having results that are too inaccurate to be worth calculating. That is not true of the kinds of highly-specific theories that people seem to be more prone to come up with in some fields. The kinds of things that even fairly recent "science" in fields such as psychology and (sadly, all too often) medicine reads more like "the world is balanced on the back of a tortoise" or "there is an evil genie that makes things fall to the ground; his name is Fred and he wears a black cape" than "continents are fixed" or "physics is deterministic, particulate, and local".
Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by Tiksi on Thursday January 28, 2016 @05:30AM (#10987426)
Well to be fair, having parents be "warmer" to their children and engage with them more probably also has positive results, regardless of the flawed reasoning for it.

And yes, young scientific fields quickly disprove themselves, that's kinda the point of science. Hard sciences like physics and chemistry also had some very very flawed theories in their youth, like aethers, alchemy, etc. but have had a few hundred years to get past that.

Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by gus_massa on Thursday January 28, 2016 @04:24PM (#10991477)
> Well to be fair, having parents be "warmer" to their children and engage with them more probably also has positive results, regardless of the flawed reasoning for it.

I agree, but imagine this:

You have a children with a bad illness. Then some moron comes and accuses you of being the cause of the illness. Let's hope he is right, otherwise he deserves to burn in hell for the eternity. (Or whatever infinite penalty is compatible with your beliefs.)

Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by vox_mollis on Thursday January 28, 2016 @12:33PM (#10989670)
70 years ago? Psychiatry still has odd ideas. The complete and total refusal of social scientists to accept the reality that behaviors are largely genetic in origin has led to this absurd proliferation of blank-slate-based crackpot theories with very low reproducibility.

Behavioral genetics is very real, but our irrational fear of ( studying genes == hitler ) is stunting the potential of social science across the board.

Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by lutusp on Thursday January 28, 2016 @12:24PM (#10989590)
> Yes, 70 years ago psychiatry had some odd ideas.

Yes, that's true, but in the name of accuracy, the Asperger's fiasco wasn't 70 years ago, it played out seven years ago, when the condition was finally abandoned after an epidemic of phony diagnoses (http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/03/health/03asperger.html).

The Recovered Memory Therapy fiasco wasn't 70 years ago, it played out in the 1990s -- you remember, when virgins could claim to have been raped and be believed (http://arachnoid.com/trouble_with_psychology)?

The homosexual fiasco wasn't 70 years ago, it played out in the 1970s, when homosexuality was finally abandoned as a diagnosis (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homosexuality_and_psychology).

But in all these cases, the abandoned diagnoses can still be offered by mental health professionals, and some still are, simply because there isn't any science sufficiently persuasive to say "no" to anything psychiatrists and psychologists care to do.

> It's frustrating that you only make these comments about psychiatry - you don't pop up in geography threads to say "Wait, what? Does this mean geographers don't still believe in fixed immovable continents?".

Geologists don't have clinics. Geologists don't issue press releases telling us how sick we all are, and how desperately in need of talk therapy.

> A therapy might be involved if a person is hearing voices, but isn't particularly bothered by them.

My point is very simple -- the health resources directed toward psychiatry and psychology, for what are fact either nonexistent or biological ailments, are wasted, and would be better spent on real science. Thomas Insel's (director of the NIMH) proposed abandonment of the DSM was a good first step (http://www.newyorker.com/tech/elements/the-rats-of-n-i-m-h), but more needs to be done.

Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by superpenny on Thursday January 28, 2016 @08:20AM (#10987949)
I think it's also worth noting that (at least in the United States) Psychiatrists and Neurologist share a certifying body -- The American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology. What's the big difference between the two specialties? When we understand the mechanism it slowly becomes neurology. This "slowly nibbling away" is by design.
Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by jxdjsks on Thursday January 28, 2016 @08:17AM (#10987929)
Well. I think you might be getting a little bit too eager with your reductionist approach to mental illness. Sure there is a large genetic component to schizophrenia - I was terrified for years that I might have it because my mother did. I think it more likely that shizophrenia is a heterogenous illness - there are many pathways to the same disease state. It is quite a bold statement to say that none of these pathways are in any way effected by the environment in which we develop. Especially given what we know about the association between early traumatic experiences and various disease states.

It may not fit nicely into your mental model of the world, but biology is extremely messy business. It appears that biological systems, although heirachical and modular are, unlike human engineering, highly interconnected across all the levels. Particularly: The health of the mind effects the health of the body and the health of the body effects the health of the mind. If you do not believe this you have not learnt enough, or like many, you have ideoligical issues with this reality.

Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by tmnvix on Thursday January 28, 2016 @08:44AM (#10988062)
Yes. It surprises me that people are so quick to so readily assume a biologically deterministic cause when these types of findings are presented. People seem too eager to discount environmental factors - even when it should be obvious to all that our biology is intimately related to our environment and circumstances.

For a good summary of the contemporary positions of the biological and environmental camps when it comes to the causes of schizophrenia I can't recommend this lecture highly enough: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QxVY2Vptfwg&feature=youtu.be

Long story short; both camps have valuable insights and a lot to learn from each other.

Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by lutusp on Thursday January 28, 2016 @12:33PM (#10989666)
> Well. I think you might be getting a little bit too eager with your reductionist approach to mental illness.

Schizophrenia is a classic case of a mental illness that isn't one, a condition that doesn't appear in people who don't have a specific genetic predisposition.

> It may not fit nicely into your mental model of the world, but biology is extremely messy business.

Yes, that's true, but according to the new finding this thread is about, biology is now able to (a) detect schizophrenia in people who lack symptoms, and (b) dismiss the possibility in those who show symptoms (for example by an actor trained to imitate the symptoms). The reason? Schizophrenia isn't a mental illness, it's a physical illness with mental symptoms.

Dustin Hoffman nailed autism in "Rain Man". If Mr. Hoffman appeared at a mental health clinic and performed his character, do you suppose he would be turned away by the psychiatrists as a fake? Now consider this alternative -- if there was a genetic test for autism (there isn't at the moment), do you suppose he would be turned away by the biologists?

> ... you have ideoligical [sic] issues with this reality.

Science isn't about ideology, it's about evidence.

Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by ptaipale on Thursday January 28, 2016 @03:37AM (#10987109)
Well, first of all, I don't think that psychiatry has for decades claimed that "schizophrenia is caused by refrigerator moms", even though the downfall of that claim may have been more due to political pressure than medical research.

And secondly, whether therapy does any good is a completely different question from what is causing schizophrenia - although here we are talking about triggering it rather than causing it.

I have a friend who came up with schizophrenia just when graduating from university, and it was indeed devastating. But the endless therapy helps him a bit.

Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by marincounty on Thursday January 28, 2016 @05:03AM (#10987356)
He was down voted because he/she cherry picked one of their easy targets, or theories? It sounds like he/she has intimate knowledge of just how deep the hole Psychiatrists, and subsequent Therapy has fallen?

Did he stereotype a entire profession--yes. If any profession has a lot of explaining, and hands on knees apologizing--it's Psychiatry, and Psychology.

Sometimes the truth hurts. Hacker news should be that place where the truth is exposed?

I'll stop, but if you don't question Psychiatry/Psychlogy after being fooled by the SSRI's, the addictive drugs, the endless office visits, and the horrid rates of therapy cures; you haven't been in the system, or you are very prone to placebo.

The latest research on schizophrenia is this; patients whom are not on long term medications have a better quality of life. Yes, it's a judgement call on the doctor, but why do I have a feeling, since the residency doesn't attract the best, and brightest anymore--little nuggets like this latest research is not passed along to these vunerable patients?

As Ricky would say to Lucy, "Psychiatry has a lot of explainin to doo?" As to Psychology, well at least they least can't prescribe.

Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by 46Bit on Thursday January 28, 2016 @08:54AM (#10988106)
Psych does have a bad history (e.g. http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF01541182) and maybe present. But the things you're raging against can help a lot.

Therapy is horribly difficult and can fall short for all sorts of reasons, ones out of anyone's control. It's helped me tremendously day-to-day, but my ultimate problems are pretty intractable.

> patients whom are not on long term medications have a better quality of life

Perhaps that their quality of life isn't so impaired is why they're not on medication? Such a short anecdote can be interpreted as suggesting anything.

Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by pja on Thursday January 28, 2016 @05:02AM (#10987355)
It’s been standard practice to treat schizophrenia with anti-psychotic drugs as the first-line treatment for decades at this point in time.

Do you have some weird grudge against psychologists?

Re:Scientists open the ‘black box’ of schizophrenia with dra... by austinjp on Thursday January 28, 2016 @03:44AM (#10987132)
More optimistically, psychologists might hope that genetically-based sub-grouping of patient cohorts might help to determine those who best respond to the various types of psychological interventions.

Of course, genetic testing and gene therapy may obviate the need for psychotherapy in some circumstances, but that's many years away.