Re:To Prevent Back Pain, Orthotics Are Out, Exercise Is In
by jschwartzi on Thursday January 28, 2016 @03:23AM
(#10987064)
If the back pain is caused by weak postural muscles or a muscular imbalance, then it's possible that exercise is correcting those deficiencies. Your muscles adapt to whatever loads they routinely bear. If you spend most of your time with a supported posture then your postural muscles will naturally weaken over time. I used to have neck and back and knee pain until I started lifting regularly.
In my experience, it hurts differently when you're damaging your body versus training your muscles. It is possible to seriously injure yourself a little at a time if you're not cognizant of this, and it's much better to err on the side of caution and progress slower than to ignore your body and risk a serious injury.
If we see a study like you say, it will almost certainly fail to control for the confounding effect of a cautious or incautious approach on injury rates.
Re:To Prevent Back Pain, Orthotics Are Out, Exercise Is In
by RyanMcGreal on Thursday January 28, 2016 @06:47AM
(#10987632)
> it hurts differently when you're damaging your body versus training your muscles
In my experience it's the difference between soreness and pain.
Ah, speculation. In 5 years, we'll be hearing how exercise causes chronic back pain, and the solution is to exercise for 6 months, then take 6 months off, because some other highly-decorated surgeon thinks it probably makes sense.