Re:Bradley Kuhn: I Think I Just Got Patented
by eru on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @03:01PM
(#1098683)
Does the author live in the US? As far as I know e.g. European patent law does require not only prior art but also prior publication.
Re:Bradley Kuhn: I Think I Just Got Patented
by gridspy on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @04:01PM
(#1098853)
Who is going to publish something that they consider obvious?
Re:Bradley Kuhn: I Think I Just Got Patented
by eru on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @07:43PM
(#1099394)
An example: Page numbers are considered obvious nowadays, but they are still in a lot of published works.
Re:Bradley Kuhn: I Think I Just Got Patented
by gridspy on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @09:13PM
(#1099570)
Can you name a recent published work wherein the subject is page numbering?
Re:Bradley Kuhn: I Think I Just Got Patented
by eru on Thursday February 04, 2010 @10:34AM
(#1100685)
Does this matter?
Any book will serve as published prior art against a patent on page numbering. It does not have to be the main subject.
Re:Bradley Kuhn: I Think I Just Got Patented
by gridspy on Thursday February 04, 2010 @03:58PM
(#1101592)
My point is that there are many small problems which we solve as engineers every day that are too trivial to publish in a paper.
It is all well and good until some moron (genius?) comes along and patents these simple ideas.
http://www.ipwatchdog.com/inventing/prior-art/
Still, this puts the burden of proof on the person claiming prior art. I'd like to see a reform of patent law that would make the infringing patent holder responsible for the legal fees for proving the prior art, if it's valid.
That would:
1. Force the potential infringer to do a more rigorous search prior to filing the patent.
2. Gives the person with prior art a little more leverage in negotiations.
Am I misguided?