News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the calorie is broken by 1_player on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @10:21AM (#10980437)
I've been fascinated by low carb diets for a while now, and in the past month I've been religiously counting everything I ingest, and found I settle naturally towards a very high fat, low carb diet (5% carbs, 25% prots, 70% fat)

My flatmate, who's dieting with me, is appaled by the amount of fat I'm eating, constantly asking me if it's healthy or whether I'm just going to get fat even if I am well below my TDEE. My response is basically "a calorie is a calorie", i.e. I'm below my TDEE => I'm losing weight.

I know that the reality is more complicated, and the article does explain that very well; satiety is more important for dieters, and there's also the unknown factor of gut microbes: am I comfortable low carbing because of satiety or just because my gut flora is different? Nobody knows actually.

This is a fascinating subject and there are far too many experts and anecdata that everybody's right and wrong at the same time. Experiment, if you feel physically good and are not overeating (by counting calories) you're on the right track. Take dieting advices with tons of salt. Make them your own.

Personally I struggle having more than two meals a day and eating more than 1800 cals (I'm 1.86m and 88 kg). If I were high carbing I'd go over the limit just to keep my hunger at bay. I once binged (on processed crap I was craving) and ate around 4K cals. I honestly don't know how to do that on low carb, and especially eating healty. Unless I eat nuts: can eat over 1K cals in nuts in a single sitting.

And whoever said you NEED to eat n times a day: shut up, you're wrong.

My advice: eat when you are hungry, eat real food, forget about macros.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by tejohnso on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:32AM (#10980959)
"My advice: eat when you are hungry, eat real food, forget about macros."

This is always my go-to response when people ask me about my diet. If you simply eat only when hungry, and only eat real food, you're going to be in decent shape on average. There is a lot of detail and difficulty hiding behind those two simple requirements though.

For example, eating only when hungry implies that we stop eating when we are no longer hungry. Avoiding binge sessions is sometimes very challenging. And accepting a simple definition of "real food" can be surprisingly challenging. Things that don't make the cut: Frozen pizzas, almost all fast food, even orange juice.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by criddell on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:14AM (#10980823)
> is appaled by the amount of fat I'm eating, constantly asking me if it's healthy or whether I'm just going to get fat

I wonder how much of the fear of fat comes from people believing the saying "you are what you eat"?

Re:Why the calorie is broken by dahart on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:32AM (#10980956)
I don't know, but I wouldn't jump to that conclusion; there are real reasons to be careful with fat.

Fat is 9 calories per gram, while carbs and proteins are 4. If you have a budget and you're counting calories, fat is more expensive per gram, so you might naturally develop an aversion to spending your budget on what appears to be less food (even if it's only appearance).

Too much fat is also unhealthy. How much is too much is still being debated, but there is a difference between a weight loss diet and a healthy diet. All things being equal, a 2000 calorie diet of buttered bacon doughnuts is still likely to cause more problems than a 2000 calorie diet of vegetables, fruits and nuts.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by 1_player on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:26PM (#10981376)
> 2000 calorie diet of buttered bacon doughnuts is still likely to cause more problems than a 2000 calorie diet of vegetables, fruits and nuts

Not to pick on you, but there's this idea that fat must come from processed crap.

What about a 2000 calorie diet of meat, (real) butter, (good) oils, cheese, nuts and vegetables? Is that unhealthy?

The jury's still out.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by dahart on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @01:36PM (#10981945)
I agree with you, and I don't feel picked on, since I didn't say fats come from processed crap.

Your example is one of a healthy diet, IMO, and fats are part of a healthy diet.

My one and only point is that too much fat, even from natural sources, is unhealthy, and the jury is not out on that, it is a known, proven fact.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by noondip on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:35PM (#10981444)
> (good) oils

Okay, I'll bite. What is a "good oil"? All oil is fat, and consuming fat causes serious health problems. The only "oil" you need are polyunsaturated fatty acids which occur naturally in whole vegetables and nuts.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by 1_player on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:38PM (#10981463)
You catch me ignorant on this.

The only oil I consume, apart from naturally occuring ones, is extra virgin olive oil, which the consensus from both sides of the fence is "it's good for you".

Re:Why the calorie is broken by noondip on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:43PM (#10981499)
Olive oil is NOT healthy. Can you explain how pouring saturated fat on a meal is supposed to improve it? Please show me where the consensus that olive oil is "good for you" is claimed to be reached.
Re:Why the calorie is broken by maxerickson on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:52PM (#10981580)
Olive oil only has a fraction of saturated fat, it is mostly unsaturated fats.

I think whatever sources you are leaning on for your claims would have the same issues that all the sources demonstrating good things about olive oil have, there is no central consensus for any of it, making that a pretty weak argument.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by noondip on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:59PM (#10981634)
Firstly, it's mostly monounsaturated fats, which are not necessary in a diet. In order to justify pouring olive oil on a meal, it would have to be really nutrient dense, but nothing could be further from the truth.
Re:Why the calorie is broken by maxerickson on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @01:00PM (#10981648)
What do you mean firstly?

You said Olive oil is NOT healthy. Can you explain how pouring saturated fat on a meal is supposed to improve it?, don't come back at me like I'm trying to mix things up.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by noondip on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @01:05PM (#10981685)
Well, can you explain how adding any saturated fat improves a meal, or not?
Re:Why the calorie is broken by maxerickson on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @01:12PM (#10981745)
I never claimed the addition of saturated fat would improve a meal. I don't think a modest amount of saturated fat makes much difference either way (I love me some butter, so I hope I'm right). I think there is a fair chance that there is some truth to all the studies of olive oil consumption that show a net benefit from consuming it.
Re:Why the calorie is broken by noondip on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @02:49PM (#10982585)
> all the studies of olive oil consumption that show a net benefit from consuming it

Well, where are they? I find it laughable how no one ever seems to be able to cite evidence exonerating unhealthy olive oil in these types of discussions.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by maxerickson on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @03:33PM (#10983029)
There's plenty of citations in industry material like this:

http://www.aboutoliveoil.org/oohealthbenefits.pdf

(Now that I've pointed you to an easily found resource, will you read the cited works?)

Re:Why the calorie is broken by noondip on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @05:45PM (#10984169)
> Commissioned by the International Olive Council

Okay, now I'm convinced you really are kidding.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by maxerickson on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @06:26PM (#10984436)
It's an industry sponsored survey of scientific research. That they included a result in it does not impugn the research.

(the citations of scientific papers are on the bottom of each page...)

Note the in industry material in my comment above. I anticipated this response, I didn't have to edit it to put that in.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by noondip on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @07:46PM (#10984982)
The citations don't support your conclusion, and neither does the entire paper itself. At best, it shows whole olives are a healthy food to eat from time to time. How can you possibly reason extracting, refining, processing and heating olives make them into "good oils"? My advice for you is, don't allow yourself to be informed by industry, and look for unbiased systematic reviews and meta-analyses instead.
Re:Why the calorie is broken by maxerickson on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @08:48PM (#10985445)
So stuff like http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16571180 or http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16954359 is bullcrap because you say so?

Anyway, have fun.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by noondip on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:24AM (#10980892)
> My flatmate, who's dieting with me, is appaled by the amount of fat I'm eating, constantly asking me if it's healthy or whether I'm just going to get fat

That's probably because a diet with 70% fat is extremely unhealthy and will likely lead to coronary atherosclerosis. Also, 5% carbs? How are you getting any nutrition in, since fruit and vegetables are almost all carbs?

Re:Why the calorie is broken by tzs on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:11PM (#10981261)
> Also, 5% carbs? How are you getting any nutrition in, since fruit and vegetables are almost all carbs?

Vegetables are often relatively high in carbs but low in total calories, and so the contribution of their carbs to your total calories can be low even if you have a lot of vegetables in your diet.

For instance, I recently had a steak and corn for dinner. The corn was 80 calories per serving, 15 g of carb, so 75% of calories from carbs. The steak was 600 calories, 3 g of carb (from the steak sauce I used, not the steak itself), with is 2% calories from carbs. I had two servings of corn with my steak, so the total meal was 760 calories, 33 g carbs, which is 17% calories from carbs.

If I had not chosen corn I probably would have chosen a can of green beans (70 calories, 7 g of carbs, which is 40% calories from carbs) which would have made the total meal 6% calories from carbs. Heck, double the green beans...two full 14.5 oz cans (almost a kilogram of green beans!), and the total for the meal would only rise to 9% calories from carbs.

Or consider salads. I use a pre-made salad mix [1] (I'm lazy). One bowl of this is 20 calories, 3 g carbs. That's 60% of calories from carbs. I use a dressing on this that is 240 calories, 4 g of carbs, so 7% calories from carbs. The salad mix combined with the dressing gives me 26 calories, 7 g carbs, so 11% calories from carbs. Recently I add some chopped up ham to this that added 200 calories, 0 g carbs, making the total salad 6% calories from carbs.

[1] http://www.freshexpress.com/product/refreshing-mixes/iceberg... and yes, the nutrition values I gave above do not match what they give on the site. I'm going by what is printed on the actual package rather than the web site, although it is a little disturbing that they are different.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by noondip on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:19PM (#10981324)
> Vegetables are often relatively high in carbs but low in total calories

Exactly, which is why you're supposed to be eating a lot of them.

> I had two servings of corn with my steak, so the total meal was 760 calories, 33 g carbs, which is 17% calories from carbs.

760 calories and not a whole lot of nutrition. For the same caloric price, you could have several salads packed with vegetables, legumes and whole grains, packed with antioxidants, vitamins, minerals and fiber.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by tzs on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @01:00PM (#10981644)
> 760 calories and not a whole lot of nutrition

Well, I do eat more than just a single meal a day. I also had a salad that day, and a sandwich on whole grain bread. It's not like every meal is a big slab of meat and a couple servings of one vegetable.

My main dietary planning since early September has been around carbs, because my glucose levels have been creeping up, even though I had not made any dietary changes. My HA1c hit 8.9 early in 2015 [1]. I cut back a bit on sugary drinks, and it dropped to 8.1 by early September. Then I started aiming for no more than 40% of calories from carbs, and by my next test 3 months later it was down to 5.9. I hadn't actually intended to cut calories, but as a completely accidental side effect my daily calories ended up half what they were before, so over that 3 months I lost 45 pounds, and have lost another 15 since then. My blood pressure is down noticeably, too.

For my 2016 food tracking spreadsheet I added a column specifically for sugar, and am thinking of modifying my "40% from carbs" goal to allow a higher percentage from carbs as long as the percentage specifically from sugar stays down. That will flip a lot more fruits and vegetables and grain-based products into the "go ahead and eat a lot of these" category.

From blood tests and food tracking, as far as I can see the only nutrient I'm low on is protein. I'm getting on average about 75-80% of what is recommended (based on the 0.36 g of protein per pound you weigh guideline). So, I like to toss in a delicious slab of meat now and then to boost the protein, like I did in my steak and corn dinner the other day.

As long as I feel fine, and my blood tests continue showing no problems, I'm just going to keep on doing what I'm doing, because it is leading to good steady weight loss and is almost effortless and should be sustainable indefinitely.

[1] And yes, this is with medication.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by maxerickson on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:26PM (#10981372)
Best not to count the liquid in the can as bean mass.
Re:Why the calorie is broken by 1_player on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:11PM (#10981256)
I don't eat fruit nor starchy vegetables, they make me very bloated and I crave more.

Greens, nuts and non-sweet fruits (olives, tomatoes, avocadoes, peppers) have negligible amount of carbs.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by noondip on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:13PM (#10981278)
You crave more because complex carbohydrates - starchy vegetables - are the food you're supposed to be eating. Have a look at Starch Solution by John McDougall, either the actual book or any videos on YouTube about it.
Re:Why the calorie is broken by 1_player on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:18PM (#10981318)
> are the food you're supposed to be eating

Who said? It's not very scientific, but if this supposedly "good for me" food makes me crave more, makes me bloated, tired, and crash after 3 hours and gives me stomach discomfort, is it really good for me?

Oh, I went through it for years, my body probably knows best.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by noondip on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:21PM (#10981337)
> Who said?

Every single civilization which has eaten predominantly carbohydrates, like root vegetables and rice, for all of human history.

Stomach discomfort is caused by fiber, is common if you're coming off a meat-heavy diet, does go away once you return to eating healthy.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by basch on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:10PM (#10981250)
health is more than weight. nutirient density is somewhat important.

"forget about macros" - > be conscious of the starch and sugars you intake. if you have the choice between potatoes and nuts, eat nuts. choose green before white. getting all your calories a day from starch isnt ideal.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by noondip on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:27PM (#10981378)
What's wrong with potatoes? Why is getting calories from starch not ideal? Please link to peer reviewed research which supports these hypotheses.
Re:Why the calorie is broken by basch on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:28PM (#10981393)
nutrient density. if you have the choice between spinach and potatoes, spinach has more other nutrients per calorie.

http://www.peertrainer.com/gfx/en_us/nut_density.jpg is an example chart i found after 10sec of googling

you might say potato is higher than chicken. but im not going to turn potato into muscle, i will turn chicken into muscle.

at the end of the day, fat and protein are necessary to survive, starch is optional.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by noondip on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:33PM (#10981428)
> spinach has more other nutrients per calorie

Erm .. so? One can't survive on spinach alone, so I don't see this as a reason not to eat potatoes, or other starches.

> im not going to turn potato into muscle, i will turn chicken into muscle.

Well, why not? Every single whole plant food has a complete amino acid profile and sufficient protein (5-10% of calories).

Re:Why the calorie is broken by basch on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:38PM (#10981462)
we are talking about losing weight, right? most american meals come with a side of fries, rice, pasta, or bread. digestible carbs like sugar and starch are the easiest thing to cut out of your diet with no other impact. you dont need to start eating some other food to make up for the nutrients you arent getting. you can just cut starches out of your diet.

i am talking about being mindful. saying "dont worry about macros" is the antithesis of paying attention to what you eat. for the most part, starches are fillers.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by noondip on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:45PM (#10981519)
> you dont need to start eating some other food to make up for the nutrients you arent getting. you can just cut starches out of your diet.

If you cut out starches, you need to replace those calories with other food. If it isn't vegetables, it'll probably be animal products, which are way less healthy than the innocent potato.

> for the most part, starches are fillers

I don't think so.

"THE potato is a very important constituent of the diet of many civilised nations, and it may be considered to furnish, with bread, the bulk of the food of the rural population of such countries as Poland and Russia. There is little doubt that the Polish or Russian peasant is nevertheless very healthy and able to do extremely hard work under trying conditions. Deficiency diseases such as beriberi, pellagra or scurvy are practically unknown in Poland."

The value of whole potato in human nutrition

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1252113/

Re:Why the calorie is broken by basch on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:55PM (#10981596)
how is any of this making the case that potatoes are better than nuts and leaves?

if the goal is to lose weight, the calories should NOT be replaced, by meat or otherwise.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by noondip on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @01:05PM (#10981684)
If the goal is to lose weight, the minimum which ought to be done is replacing fats (9 calories per gram) with carbohydrate (4 calories per gram). That's why eating a potato over nuts is recommended (not that you shouldn't eat nuts - they are great in their own way).
Re:Why the calorie is broken by 1_player on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:15PM (#10981295)
The consensus in bodybuilding is to eat your daily requirement of proteins, enough fats (fats are NECESSARY for hormones. Also, no cholesterol == no testosterone), and everything else is up to you.

While I would tend to agree with you, apparently there's many people that thrive on starchy food (potatoes, rice). There's some unknown mechanism at work here, most probably it's the gut flora diversity.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by noondip on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:28PM (#10981392)
> no cholesterol == no testosterone

Complete nonsense. Cholesterol = animal products, which contain estrogen, which lower testosterone. You don't need cholesterol in a healthy diet, in fact it's completely antithetical to healthy eating.

Re:Why the calorie is broken by 1_player on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:34PM (#10981441)
> Like other steroid hormones [i.e. estradiol/estrogens/progesterone], testosterone is derived from cholesterol

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Testosterone#Biosynthesis

Re:Why the calorie is broken by noondip on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:36PM (#10981449)
That's talking about the cholesterol made in your liver - the only cholesterol you need.