News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by CyberDildonics on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @08:43AM (#10979948)
It can be solved by an exchange that makes trades every second or on some time interval that is minuscule to a person but enormous to a computer.

People seem to defend HFT for some reason (the front running kind, not the necessary arbitrage kind) but they never seem to answer the question of why someone who is not an HFT firm would want to trade on an exchange that caters to high frequency traders (as basically every exchange does).

Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by kasey_junk on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @10:12AM (#10980368)
> People seem to defend HFT for some reason (the front running kind, not the necessary arbitrage kind)

I'm not defending the front running kind. The argument is that the front running kind (which is in no way actual front running and is instead latency arbitrage) is the same as, and fundamentally a requirement of the arbitrage kind.

Further, most peoples model of what latency arbitrage actually is, is so flawed as to create strong biases when they shouldn't exist.

Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by grandinj on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @10:57AM (#10980694)
"latency arbitrage" ?

The euphemism HF traders use to help themselves sleep at night.

Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by kasey_junk on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:15AM (#10980826)
Thats one way to describe it. Another way to describe it is "hey prices at 2 different venues get out of whack some times, when that happens there is an opportunity to make money by bringing them back into alignment".

We don't assume other kinds of middle-men require sleep aids when they do this kind of behavior (and in fact we usually encourage it), so I don't know why HFT folks would need them either.

Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by grandinj on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @02:42PM (#10982492)
And confidence tricksters perform trust arbitrage.

This is all just ways of saying HFT is exploiting a loop-hole in a system to make money for themselves.

They could all be eliminated overnight and the free-market system would not notice their absence at all.

They don't provide a service to anyone besides themselves, they don't provide liquidity, they are nothing except parasites.

Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by tptacek on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @01:26PM (#10981848)
This is a little like saying the CAP theorem is a euphemism that distributed systems designers use to help themselves sleep at night.
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by minimax on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @09:30AM (#10980132)
... they never seem to answer the question of why someone who is not an HFT firm would want to trade on an exchange that caters to high frequency traders (as basically every exchange does).

There are a number of incorrect assumptions built into your comment (most notably that prop HFT are the only ones using algos to trade), but the simple answer to this question is that those exchanges have larger displayed size at better prices.

Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by CyberDildonics on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:17AM (#10980840)
> most notably that prop HFT are the only ones using algos to trade

Can you point out where I made that assumption?

Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by cli on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @08:48AM (#10979962)
>It can be solved by an exchange that makes trades every second or on some time interval that is minuscule to a person but enormous to a computer.

I do not see how that will solve the problem. Suppose firm A and firm B both want to buy stock X at prize Z. There is only enough X at prize Z for one of those firms. Both firms send their trade orders withing milliseconds of each other. In your time interval scheme, which firm gets to buy the stock?

Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by ctlby on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @09:42AM (#10980191)
CyberDildonics is basically proposing frequent batch auctions as described in the Budish paper. It won't work, largely for reason you state. The appropriate solution is for exchanges to add a _random_ delay to each order (emphasis on _random_, a fixed delay a la IEX does nothing). ParFX is doing just this.
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by kasey_junk on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @09:57AM (#10980273)
Random delays already exist. The infrastructure of every exchange introduces them. Its a standard part of any HFT model to think about what happens when you hit one. It certainly doesn't remove the speed game.

I think a better way to change exchanges is to dramatically decimalize the price levels. Right now the difference between 2 price levels a) adds a floor to the minimum spread and b) prevents strategies from truly competing on price requiring them to compete on time.

Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by minimax on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:09AM (#10980782)
I think a better way to change exchanges is to dramatically decimalize the price levels.

The idea that reduced tick sizes would force traders to compete on price rather than time is a popular HN market microstructure solution, but it's wrong or at least partly wrong.

1) Liquidity taking strategies will still "compete on time" in order to trade at the most favorable prices. Market making strategies will still "compete on time" in order to avoid getting picked off.

2) Inverted fee venues and midpoint order types offer sophisticated traders the opportunity to trade at prices within a 1 penny spread. If you watch the tape for a stock like ZNGA you will see this type of trading.

3) There are a number of high priced / high volume stocks that don't trade at a penny spread. GOOG is a good example. Do you find GOOG trading to be somehow cheaper, more orderly or efficient than e.g. MSFT? The GOOG spread is almost never a penny and is regularly over 20 cents. If the benefits are there, they ought to be obvious.

Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by kasey_junk on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:26AM (#10980909)
First, let me make it clear, I don't view market participants competing on time as a problem and physics means it will always be a component of the price of the risk associated with trading. But if we are going to be making changes to markets, I'd much rather change the pricing requirements than adding esoteric random time differences, or assuming batch auctions will make things better.

The reason I like reducing tick sizes (and I mean dramatically like 1/1000th or more) is less about the bid ask spread at the middle, but rather the competition at the +1 levels. A lot of the latency advantage right now is in being able to cancel a few levels near the midpoint while leaving tons of other orders stacked.

Reducing tick sizes would make these deep stacking strategies less viable, which seems (though I have no proof) like it would make the positions of the market makers less risky in a systematic way.

As for GOOG vs MSFT, I think that is obviously explained by the much higher price of GOOG right? Nothing is going to make holding a stock that costs more less risky, even speed.

Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by minimax on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:03PM (#10981186)
I thought you were making the argument that reducing tick sizes would reduce the amount of effort put into reducing latency (or reducing the overall amount of prop HFT volume), but I guess I was wrong about that. The idea that reducing tick sizes would ultimately reduce market maker risk by making certain quoting strategies less viable is interesting.
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by kasey_junk on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:10PM (#10981245)
I think ultimately I'm just not being clear about something I'm not certain of in any case, but a better restatement of my position might be:

"Having some participants whose primary competitive edge is speed is not in and of itself bad, but speed advantages tend to consolidate around a few natural monopolies, which is. So if we could add something else into the mix that allows for other participants to compete outside of those monopolies, that is good. Dramatically reduced tick sizes would do that, would at times make the spreads smaller, and might even make market making less risky systematically and doesn't seem to have the downsides of other options proposed".

Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by minimax on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:43PM (#10981503)
Do you think there are monopolies in electronic market making? I think there are tons of firms out there trying to be good at it in different asset classes, and a few that are really good at it in lots of asset classes. I'm not sure it looks like "a few natural monopolies."
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by kasey_junk on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @01:04PM (#10981680)
I don't know if we are there yet, but it certainly seems to be trending towards consolidation. I don't have any data to back that up, just my impression from around town.

Of course that could have been due to macro trends around volatility that have reversed recently as well, I suppose.

Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by ctlby on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @10:49AM (#10980640)
Let me clarify: my random delay shuffles incoming orders, while random exchange delays (outside of CME iLink games) do not. Removing determinism hugely hurts speed.

The value of further decimalization seems questionable. It would in all cases reduce displayed size. Would transaction costs still decline due to tighter spreads? For the liquid lower-priced stocks, probably. For stocks whose natural spread is > 1 cent (most of the expensive stuff), certainly not. For everything else, hard to say.

Maybe a Japan/Europe-style tick increment schedule is a good compromise.

Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by CyberDildonics on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:19AM (#10980860)
If there is more demand than supply, wouldn't you expect the price to go up?
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by tptacek on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:07PM (#10981223)
You're not allowing it to, because your proposal quantized the market! That's what it means to batch trades and execute them at an interval: the price can't change inside that interval.
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by CyberDildonics on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @01:12PM (#10981739)
So you cancel the order, raise the price and let it go another cycle. Why wouldn't the seller want that?
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by tptacek on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @01:17PM (#10981783)
Yes, but now you haven't accomplished what your proposal sets out to do, because the fastest people to the quantized order book get the best prices.
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by CyberDildonics on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @02:39PM (#10982464)
How? In every quantized unit of time everyone would be treated equally. If there is more demand than supply the prices goes up until there is not more demand than supply. This is also not even taking into account orders having ranges acceptable prices, which would add much more flexibility and granularity without needing more temporal resolution.
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by tptacek on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @02:45PM (#10982524)
I don't think you've thought this through very carefully. Most orders in the market aren't "market orders"; they specify a price. Meanwhile, assume you resolve pricing in an automated auction: there's a spectrum of prices. Who gets the better prices?
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by CyberDildonics on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @04:06PM (#10983363)
If prices are given as a floor for selling and ceiling for buying they can be fit in a fair and methodical way through many different methods with any remainder being left over for the next tick. I'm surprised it is even such a controversial idea that a fair and fluid exchange can be made without resorting to a first come first serve structure.
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by tptacek on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @04:13PM (#10983429)
This suggestion supposes that there is a reasonable "floor" and "ceiling" for prices in batch auctions. But in fact that spread of prices is exactly what market makers figure out organically.

If you instead mean that individual traders could input orders with floor and ceiling prices, that's something that already exists, but now you're back to the original problem of resolving whose orders execute when (inevitably) most of the orders don't match.

Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by CyberDildonics on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:58PM (#10986384)
It's not back to the same problem, there are many ways to do it including but not limited to matching the sells with the lowest floors to the buys with the highest ceilings, working inward from the extremes of the spread. Why are you so convinced that a fair exchange is impossible?
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by ctlby on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @09:49AM (#10980228)
> they never seem to answer the question of why someone who is not an HFT firm would want to trade on an exchange that caters to high frequency traders.

There are network effects in trading: people go to transact where everyone else is transacting. Because HFT is allowed on the most popular venues, the economic thing to do is hold your nose and trade there too. This is true even if HFT somehow makes the venues "worse" (which it doesn't).

Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by CyberDildonics on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:17AM (#10980847)
If HFT doesn't make those venues worse, then how are they making money?
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by ctlby on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:42AM (#10981019)
Makers collect the spread from participants who want to transact right now (the price of immediacy). "Real" investors are better off because they paid someone to take a position of their hands that they didn't want. They made their trading problem someone else's.

Takers exploit the option value of resting orders by trading when "fair value" moves but those orders don't. "Real" investors are better off because they cheaply acquired a security they may hold for years (the fact that the price will shortly move against them by a penny or two is irrelevant). Market makers are worse off--but they're HFT guys, and it's not really your problem.

Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by CyberDildonics on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:51AM (#10981090)
Do "real" traders want microsecond immediacy? I would think a person would rather have a better price, even if it means waiting a whole second.
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by yummyfajitas on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @03:04PM (#10982740)
There is a simple flag you can set (it's called "Add Liquidity Only" or "Post Only", depending on the venue) which will result in HFT's never trading with you. Strangely, most "real traders" never set this flag.

https://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2014/how_to_not_get_rippe...

The reason is that it's not a matter of waiting a whole second and being guaranteed a fill. It's placing an order and accepting execution risk; maybe you get a fill, maybe you are stuck holding a tanking stock.

Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by mrchicity on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @10:46PM (#10986082)
If you define HFTs as passive spread/rebate-capturing single instrument market-makers, then yes, but many prop HFTs operate a "hybrid" model where they sometimes cross the spread to flatten their book, or cross if an arbitrage presents itself. There are even HFT strategies that are primarily liquidity taking.
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by ctlby on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:10PM (#10981247)
Obviously not. Humans just want something that feels like "now." That this has changed from seconds to milliseconds to microseconds is an inevitable consequence of the rules of the game--and is completely irrelevant to you. Your horizon is much, much longer than that of the professional trader to whom these details matter.
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by CyberDildonics on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @01:13PM (#10981751)
So a professional trader is not a person and they do care about microsecond as opposed to seconds? That sounds like a bot, not a person.
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by tptacek on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @01:35PM (#10981938)
Another place people seem to get jumbled up in these discussions is in comparing institutional traders to individual retail traders.

A person buying or selling individual stocks for their own portfolio isn't impacted by HFT at all. Their orders probably never see a real exchange. Instead, internalizers pay extra money to offer brokerage customers the best possible prices for what they're looking to trade.

That's because HFTs aren't the apex predator in the markets. Informed institutional traders like Goldman are. Market making operations are built around mitigating the risk of getting run over by giant block trades from institutions. When those happen, they take out whole swathes of the order book and leave adverse price changes in their wake.

An electronic market maker will pay a premium to make safe profits off the spread of retail orders, because to a first approximation none of those orders are going to take out the whole book.

Meanwhile, among institutional traders, there are two kinds of firms to look at.

The first kind, the Royal Banks of Canada of the world, are getting paid a tidy sum of money to make large block trades for the cheapest possible price. The RBC trader has knowledge that the rest of the market doesn't: many tens of thousands of shares of something are about to trade, and that trade is going to move the market. They make money by trying to disguise their intent, so that instead of the market price reflecting that intent, they can capture the premium and leave everyone else in the market to hold the bag.

Those kinds of traders hate HFT.

The other kind, the Vanguards of the world, buy or sell based on long-term strategies. They're buying CSCO or MMM to fill out an index. They want the best possible price, of course, but they mostly care about determinism and low cost of trades.

Those kinds of traders like HFT. (You can see the Chief Investment Officer of Vanguard, the world's most trustworthy mutual fund company, saying that repeatedly and emphatically). HFTs reduce spreads and make trading cheaper, and Vanguard doesn't earn profits by taking it out of the hides of their immediate counterparties.

As a public policy matter, I'm not sure why I'm supposed to support regulations that increase Vanguard's cost of trades so that an equities desk at RBC can charge higher premiums to fleece the markets on behalf of their hedge fund clients.

Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by CyberDildonics on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @04:11PM (#10983412)
All of this is misdirection to the point that high frequency traders definitely make money, but it extremely difficult to justify what they add to the market. People making decisions don't want to trade somewhere with high frequency traders and they don't need to for any technical reason.
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by kasey_junk on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:02PM (#10981182)
If they didn't, they aren't required to pay for it. If they want to wait they can. Better yet, if they want the exchange to wait for them until the price gets to be what they want, they can do that as well, without paying for any immediacy at all.
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by andylei on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:09PM (#10981238)
when there was no HFT and market makers were humans, you had to wait a long time for your trades AND spreads were huge (aka, prices were worse).
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by CyberDildonics on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @01:16PM (#10981765)
You are making an assumption that computers mean high frequency trading. We can use computers to trade without having high frequency traders.
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by tptacek on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:04PM (#10981193)
The same way market makers have made money since prices were literally printed on a stream of tape: by outcompeting other market makers to capture spreads.
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by kasey_junk on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:29AM (#10980936)
They get paid to bridge demand over time. By efficiently doing this they can make the venues better in aggregate and still make money.
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by CyberDildonics on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:52AM (#10981098)
Does the demand between millionths of a second need to be bridged?
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by tptacek on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:05PM (#10981208)
No, there is probably nothing especially productive about pricing things at that level of granularity. But speed is a reasonable figure of merit that allows different algorithmic trading firms to compete for the business of making markets, rather than having all of market-making owned by one of the big investment banks.
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by kasey_junk on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:54AM (#10981112)
No, but by being able to react fast they can price what the service of bridging more efficiently, and thus more cheaply to those taking part in the service.
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by CyberDildonics on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @01:18PM (#10981789)
How is that not circular logic?
Re:High-Speed Firms Now Oversee Almost All Stocks at NYSE Floor by kasey_junk on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @01:46PM (#10982027)
Market Makers sell the service of taking on the risk of bridging prices for a good over time. The price for that service is directly correlated with the amount of risk they take on.

HFT reduce the risk of the inventory they hold by being able to adjust the prices of that inventory fast.

HFT Market Makers can therefore price the service cheaper as their risk is less, due to the speed.