Apps on the Marketplace are deployed to a device and run locally, offline - complete with an intricate permissions model. The only 'web' aspect is being written in HTML/JS/CSS and the extent to which they integrate with the cloud. No less open than the github hosted, Android app scenario you mention. Maybe Firefox OS does need an f-droid equivalent for a free app catalogue though, if and when Mozilla pull the Marketplace servers down.
So be aware of the distinction between mobile web 'apps' and mobile web sites.
So like Android, except using HTML/JS/CSS which I'd consider either an irrelevant implementation detail or a negative.
No less open than the github hosted, Android app scenario you mention.
Sure, no less and no more. The real issues are whether the user is allowed to run the app without explicit permission from the OS vendor, and whether they're required to hand control of their data to a third party. Once we have the answers to those questions, whether the app is written in JS or Java or Swift or C++ doesn't really matter in terms of openness.
That is, I can't just create an app and throw it up on a server like I can with a website. It needs to be "approved" first. That's a HUGE barrier to openness that the web never had, and hopefully never will have in the future.
And, even though mobile apps run natively, I don't think one can be very confident that they're any more private than a typical website...analytics & the drive for data is there regardless of medium.
I agree completely about the privacy thing though. I guess it's a bit easier to see when a native app is sending data over the network with the right tools but in general, there's just as much room for abuse with either model.
This argument is made frequently, and I don't get it. With a typical web app, you have no idea what the backend is doing, and your data is stored on servers owned by third parties. At any time they can revoke your access, go out of business, share your data with others, or change the app in user-unfriendly ways. An open source Android app that runs and stores data locally (perhaps with an option for cloud storage) seems much more "open" than that.