News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YC Startup Going into Beta: Reble.FM Music Sharing by ajkirwin on Tuesday February 05, 2008 @11:14AM (#109770)
It's an interesting idea, for sure, but depending on just how you bought your music, you (the user) could get screwed.

Take for instance, buying mp3s from Amazon, and using Reble.FM. That's a violation of your agreement with Amazon. And other things may have similar restrictions.

Of course, with illegally downloaded content, you have no worries about how you can legally use it.

Re:YC Startup Going into Beta: Reble.FM Music Sharing by imsteve on Tuesday February 05, 2008 @11:46AM (#109790)
Who cares about EULAs?
Re:YC Startup Going into Beta: Reble.FM Music Sharing by ajkirwin on Tuesday February 05, 2008 @12:01PM (#109796)
Well, people were discussing the legality of such a service, so..
Re:YC Startup Going into Beta: Reble.FM Music Sharing by imsteve on Tuesday February 05, 2008 @02:31PM (#109853)
EULAs are generally not legally binding. So no.
Re:YC Startup Going into Beta: Reble.FM Music Sharing by ajkirwin on Tuesday February 05, 2008 @03:29PM (#109888)
I'm more referring to the Terms of Service of something like AmazonMP3, which specifically and categorically says that you cannot do exactly what this site does.
Re:YC Startup Going into Beta: Reble.FM Music Sharing by imsteve on Tuesday February 05, 2008 @06:37PM (#109987)
Learn the definition of "illegal".
Re:YC Startup Going into Beta: Reble.FM Music Sharing by pius on Tuesday February 05, 2008 @11:30PM (#110122)
A EULA, if written properly, is legally binding but violating it is not illegal in the criminal sense; it's a tort issue. If we were talking about violating the DMCA, however, it would be illegal.
Re:YC Startup Going into Beta: Reble.FM Music Sharing by imsteve on Wednesday February 06, 2008 @05:26PM (#110506)
Legal advice on the internet...

morons.

Re:YC Startup Going into Beta: Reble.FM Music Sharing by pius on Wednesday February 06, 2008 @10:50PM (#110667)
I figured it went without saying that a comment on a forum should not be construed as legal advice and that one should seek the professional advice of a licensed attorney for that purpose. I'll say it now for completeness.