Sure, if A and B sit still for 8 hours there is no difference. But, many people are constantly in motion.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-2163173/Toddlers-d...
"I'm still pretty sure that calories-in/calories-out theory is more-or-less correct."
Counting calories-in as calories absorbed is not exactly tangential, it may very well be the essence of the conversation.
It's quite simple: if you are gaining weight, eat less. The variation between calories marked and calories absorbed is not great enough to fundamentally matter.
Physics.
> There's plenty of anecdotal evidence indicating significant variance among individuals.
However, research evidence disagrees. So, the most likely culprit in the variance reported anecdotally isn't different BMR or efficiency of digestion, but different (even delusional) calorie-counting approximations.
From where do you derive this certainty? There's plenty of anecdotal evidence indicating significant variance among individuals. Simply less efficient absorption of ingested calories would obviously make a huge difference, and I don't think there's any reason to think everyone absorbs calories with identical efficiency is there?