News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YC Startup Going into Beta: Reble.FM Music Sharing by axod on Tuesday February 05, 2008 @08:56AM (#109699)
So streaming a friends music collection to your PC is fine, but streaming it to an ipod isn't? I'm not sure the legalities of this hold water personally. Such muddiness when it comes to this sort of thing.
Re:YC Startup Going into Beta: Reble.FM Music Sharing by greendestiny on Tuesday February 05, 2008 @09:42AM (#109716)
It'll be interesting to see how it plays out legally. I'm glad some people are prepared to push the laws even if I'm not sure I'd take that risk in my own startup. I guess the legal analogy they're going for here is that you are lending your friend the song, just like lending a physical CD. It sounds pretty reasonable but the law isn't really defined by what sounds reasonable.

I think with the restrictive nature of this service the RIAA et al might see it as being in line with their view on a music purchasors license.

Re:YC Startup Going into Beta: Reble.FM Music Sharing by PJCrosier on Tuesday February 05, 2008 @09:44AM (#109720)
Right, the FAQ puts emphasis on you streaming one song at a time to people you know - I don't see how this is different from streaming ten songs to ten people you don't know, you're still sending music to people who don't own a copy of it. Not that I agree with the way the music industry seems to be going, but I imagine they could come knocking wanting a big piece of your pie?