News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by Animats on Monday January 25, 2016 @02:05PM (#10969143)
Your tax dollars at work. The auto industry fought most of the improvements that make that safety improvement possible. They fought seat belts. They fought air bags. They fought crumple zones. They lost.

Except Volvo, which was usually ahead of regulations on safety. They had each of those things before they were mandated.

Volvo's CEO has announced that they want to eliminate all deaths in Volvo cars by 2020. He also says that if a self-driving car has an accident, it's the manufacturer's fault and the manufacturer's financial responsibility.

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by Grishnakh on Monday January 25, 2016 @02:31PM (#10969324)
>Your tax dollars at work.

Wrong.

This video and test were done by the IIHS, an insurance-industry funded groups. The DOT crash tests are lame; it took the IIHS to push offset-frontal crash tests like this. The Federal government thinks that all auto crashes are frontal head-on crashes with no offset whatsoever.

IIHS and European tests are far better, but as usual, the US standards are stupid and backwards, just like they are for vehicle lighting and everything else. The DOT requirement for those idiotic "sealed beam" headlights are what kept the fronts of cars looking so ugly for so long, while the Europeans had moved to better-designed halogen bulbs and housing long before but couldn't export them to the US.

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by sangnoir on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @08:00AM (#10973165)
>>Your tax dollars at work.

> Wrong.

>This video and test were done by the IIHS

I believe GP was not referring to video, but to the safety legislation leading to starkly improved safety performance of the 2009 vehicle (I thought their second line made this very clear)

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by MCRed on Monday January 25, 2016 @02:35PM (#10969363)
In short this is a result of the principle-agent problem. Politicians can be influenced. The government has little time to get in, and when regulations are set they are rarely updated... meanwhile the IIHS helping insurers save money (by setting correct car insurance premiums) also sparked consumer demand for high safety ratings when shopping for cars.

This is very much the free market at work. Money (which people like to call "Greed") drives both consumers and insurers to find the scientifically best car. Insurers have more appropriate loses, and customers have fewer deaths (or a better safety level for their dollars spent).

The IIHS makes the knowledge about car safety much less asymmetric in the market.

The UL does a similar thing, and I think this is the model that is more effective.

It doesn't take an act of congress for the IIHS to come up with a new test and new standards as technology improves and new areas of risk are discovered!

Edit: I see my parent is being downvoted. He pointed out the basic facts of the situation, but since it was not sufficiently authoritarian he is being downvoted. I feel this site is anti-intellectual.

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by __jal on Monday January 25, 2016 @03:58PM (#10969894)
That is a narrative that (correct or not) explains U.S. car standards. But I'm pretty sure that, last time I was there, government and politicians exist in Europe. What's the explanation for regulation that (apparently, at least for the GP poster) works better?
Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by yvdriess on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @05:17AM (#10972695)
A vastly lower lobby magnitude?
Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by mulmen on Monday January 25, 2016 @03:58PM (#10969895)
Do you have examples of the auto industry fighting safety features? I used to own an early 70s Oldsmobile Toronado which was available with both ABS and airbags. A quick Google search suggests that Chrysler and Ford had similar braking systems in 1971, possibly even better. ABS was not required by US law until 2011. 40 years after the US domestics first offered it.

I believe Ford made a big deal out of their padded dashboards in the 1950s as well but I would have to dig up references to that.

While Volvo has a great safety record they are not even close to the only manufacturer with a history of adding safety features to their cars. Safety is good business, the US domestics have known this for decades.

The 1971 Oldsmobile Torornado brochure prominently features ABS and specifically calls out the safety features available in that year: http://www.lov2xlr8.no/brochures/olds/71toro/bilder/6.jpg

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by mturmon on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:37PM (#10970118)
The US auto industry fought air bags for about two decades, saying they were too expensive and that people did not want them: http://www.csmonitor.com/1988/0519/abelt.html

"Top Ford Motor Company executives went so far as to arrange a meeting with President Nixon to plead against a federal regulation that would have required air bags in all cars, starting with 1973 models. The meeting had the desired effect: Mr. Nixon ordered the regulation quashed. Eleven years after the 1971 meeting, a transcript from secret Oval Office tapes disclosed the conversation."

I believe the Toronado air bags might have been offered just to provide a tool to say consumers did not want them.

Earlier on, they also fought seat belts. Then later, they fought for state laws mandating seat belt use by drivers, just so they could say the airbags were not necessary in the presence of seat belts. And a bunch of other stuff. Classic cartel behavior.

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by Camillo on Monday January 25, 2016 @07:20PM (#10971071)
I don't even understand their logic. Why not simply ask the government to ban or restrict the use of old cars without those safety features, after a short transition period? That would boost sales by forcing motorists to upgrade. Emission regulations in Europe work that way and they are a boon for the auto industry.
Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by pm24601 on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @02:57AM (#10972367)
> Emission regulations in Europe work that way and they are a boon for the auto industry.

For some reason, VW didn't see it that way wrt the diesel emissions.

Maybe you need to recheck your understanding of other motivations.

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by Camillo on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @05:26AM (#10972717)
I said that auto companies could pursue their self-interest by turning regulations to their advantage, rather than opposing them. I didn't say they would embrace environmentalism in the truest depth of their hearts. Accepting emission standards for the entire industry and then cheating on them is fully consistent for an actor driven by self-interest, as long as they think they won't get caught.

Given the obviousness of the above, the real question is how you came to make such a silly post. My best guess is that you simplified the positions into "companies accept emission standards = companies GOOD on environment, but VW cheating = VW BAD on environment", and that's how you saw a contradiction. Please take a bit longer to think your posts through.

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by pm24601 on Friday January 29, 2016 @01:04AM (#10993767)
O.k. Let me be more explicit. Automobile companies have a different self-interest than you think they should. (As demonstrated by VW's action)

VW has over 450,000 people - all viewing the world differently ( as demonstrated by VW's corporate actions differently)

Out of 450,000+, excluding the dealerships, not one agreed with you enough to blow the whistle.

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by Dirlewanger on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:18PM (#10970012)
Before Ralph Nader was the face of the Green Party and the the 2008 darkhorse candidate in the 2008 election, he was the bane of the automotive industry. Check out his book Unsafe at Any Speed.

GM's response to the aforementioned? One of petulance and cowardice. They had to be hauled into Congress, kicking and screaming of course, before anything was done.

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by fnordfnordfnord on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:30PM (#10970083)
I know there was auto-industry resistance to moving away from sealed-beam headlamps.

In general I think it's widely agreed that all businesses almost universally tend to oppose most forms of gov't imposed change.

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by forinti on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:18PM (#10970017)
I think they fought all these items not because they didn't want to sell them, but because they would make more money selling them 10x more expensive to 20% of their customers.
Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by gtrubetskoy on Monday January 25, 2016 @03:16PM (#10969639)
> Except Volvo

and Saab, which was a point of contention when they were acquired by GM (Saab people insisted on safety, GM put profit first) and probably is the reason Saab (the original) is no longer

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by holyoly on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:21PM (#10970030)
There was an episode of Top Gear where they dropped a Saab and BMW on their roof from 8 feet in the air. IIRC, the Saab survived, and was able to even open it's doors. The BMW was basically flattened.
Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by brazzledazzle on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:45PM (#10970177)
No biggie, people are pretty bendy right?
Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by tkinom on Monday January 25, 2016 @02:25PM (#10969294)
Does it mean we don't need auto insurance any more when/if I get a Volvo self-driving car?

That's a claim that can change auto insurance big time.

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by rtkwe on Monday January 25, 2016 @02:44PM (#10969427)
Until there's no human control available drivers will still have to have insurance. Even after that it'll take some fight to get auto companies to accept liability for failures instead of the 'driver' (or owner I guess since there's not really a driver in a fully self driving car). Rates for fully automatic cars should be drastically lower though once the insurance companies have a way to gauge the risk of crash for each car.

If I had to guess there will probably be tests like the Institute for Highway Safety does but to test autonomous car software, maybe mostly simulated so they can run a huge number of tests again and again (a Matrix-for-Cars).

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by SilasX on Monday January 25, 2016 @02:49PM (#10969454)
IMHO, the big problem is in statutorily capping damages. Generally, punitive damage increase with the depth of the pockets of party responsible for the death. That makes it hard to insure. But once it can be capped and precisely accounted for, SDC makers could easily self-insure and take over insurance cost from riders.
Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by staticautomatic on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:49PM (#10970210)
I don't understand what caps or punitive damages have to do with it. Most venues don't have caps at all, and only rarely does an insurer get stuck paying for punitive damages. In the real world these things have little effect on the amount of money insurance companies actually pay, so I don't see why they'd have much of any effect on underwriting.
Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by SilasX on Monday January 25, 2016 @05:12PM (#10970378)
>I don't understand what caps or punitive damages have to do with it. Most venues don't have caps at all, and only rarely does an insurer get stuck paying for punitive damages.

Yeah, that's the problem; it means you can't insure away the problem, and each jury gets told to slap on a high enough penalty to ensure the SDC maker "never does it again", and you know how that goes.

The problem isn't the insurer's solvency, but the SDC maker's.

One venue that has caps, for similar reasons, is vaccines. Because vaccines are safe and necessary, we need a way to ensure vaccine makers exist and aren't sued to bankruptcy over the inevitable few deaths, so there's a special system for ensuring compensation of the victims, and makers can accurately set aside a known quantify of money for those deaths.

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by Animats on Monday January 25, 2016 @03:14PM (#10969621)
Cars can be leased with an operating lease that includes maintenance and insurance. This is common for businesses that lease cars and trucks. Businesses get a fixed cost known in advance, and the business doesn't face any unexpected costs. That arrangement would work for self-driving cars.
Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by msravi on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @03:48AM (#10972464)
Volvo buses on the other hand have had a really poor safety record, at least here in India. Here's one incident for example:

http://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Hyderabad/45-killed-as-b...

And it's not just this. I've personally witnessed at least 2 Volvos on fire on Bangalore roads, although thankfully, there weren't any fatalities. The positioning of the fuel tank is reportedly flawed in these buses.

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by ricardobeat on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @01:00PM (#10974761)
I wonder what prevented the people trapped from breaking the glass windows at the sides or back of the bus? I always imagined that would be the first action in case of fire. Missing safety hammers? Crushed until they could not move?
Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by kylegordon on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @04:57AM (#10972661)
"pierced the bus where the diesel tank was fitted, sparking off the fire."

Diesel doesn't burn in open air, without at least a wick and an existing source of ignition.

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by fanf2 on Monday January 25, 2016 @07:20PM (#10971074)
Another eye-opening video is this one of an old-ish Volvo estate vs a new Renault Modus.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qBDyeWofcLY

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by lazyant on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:36PM (#10970115)
Today the truck industry still fights any safety measures, rest times for drivers etc, the bar is way lower than for cars, or see the loopholes in safety for moving vans.
Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by Thlom on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @05:20AM (#10972699)
The blind zone around a truck is enormous, but manufacturers apparently don't want to do anything to improve this except adding mirrors, so the responsibility is laid on pedestrians and cyclist to stay out of the invisible blind zone.
Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by redblacktree on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @04:50PM (#10976406)
What are the other options? Cameras?
Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by raisedbyninjas on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @01:03PM (#10981670)
Blind spot monitoring sensors.
Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by Kluny on Monday January 25, 2016 @02:25PM (#10969287)
I was told this story by a car nerd friend, and I won't guarantee its accuracy (feel free to confirm or deny if you have more information.)

When Volvo began making cars, they were very beautiful, artistically designed instant classics, like this one: https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/99/b5/39/99b539384...

The founder of the company was passionate about making and driving beautiful cars, and he succeeded and built a pretty impressive company on that. However, he didn't pay much attention to safety, and died in a car wreck.

His wife inherited the company, and instead of selling off the assets and retiring, decided to take the helm and begin producing the safest cars possible. Ever since, they've been on the leading edge of safety development. The cars weren't quite as pretty, but they didn't kill as many people.

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/df/1988-199...

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by onre on Monday January 25, 2016 @02:40PM (#10969401)
Not true, neither of the founders died in a car accident.

Volvo had a very strong safety emphasis already in the '50s, introducing many firsts in the automotive safety field. In that decade they introduced shoulder belts as a world first and padded dashboard as an European first (Tucker had this already in '40s but only 51 cars were ever made).

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by masklinn on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:18PM (#10970011)
> In that decade they introduced shoulder belts as a world first

And ultimately decided to make the patent (US 3043625) license-free and open (essentially copyleft)

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by masklinn on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:35PM (#10970108)
If onre's comment doesn't suffice, your picture is the backside of a P1800ES. It was released in the early 70s. Before it, during the 60s, Volvo had started using 3-point seatbelts (front and back), padded dashboards, rear-facing child seats, crumple zones and head restraints.
Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by mturmon on Monday January 25, 2016 @07:02PM (#10970992)
The three-point seat belt that Volvo introduced (first to the market) looked like this:

http://web.origin.volvocars.com/SiteCollectionImages/TopNavi...

A friend had a sporty two-seater Volvo P1800, and it had this exact seat belt clasp. It felt like something out of an airplane - solid, metal, no-nonsense - and it basically was, because the designer used to do ejection seats at Saab.

Re:A small 2009 car demolishes a 1959 Chevy in a crash test ... by Kluny on Monday January 25, 2016 @10:16PM (#10971633)
Ha, I'll tell my friend to go climb a tree then. Still, it would have been a nice story if it was true.